2.0 Problem with 1:1 / NAT Reflection / need help or suggestions please

[caldwell]

Current setup is WAN (.157) and LAN interface.

WAN has a Virtual IP of .158.

Have set 1:1 NAT to point .158 to an internal 192.168.5.5 address.

Have rules on the WAN interface allowing access to port 443 for .158 -> internal IP.

Have NO/zero NAT Port Forwards set up.

Outside users can connect to .158 and get the internal web server.

Internal users try to hit the external IP, the pfsense -apparently- is redirecting the request correctly.  The firewall log shows a connection from user1 to 192.168.5.5 with TCP:S.  If we review the web server log, it shows a connection from the IP address of the FIREWALL, not the user1 IP address.

Then the connection never goes any further.

I have UNCHECKED
->Advanced
  -> NAT
      -> Disable NAT Reflection for port forwards

I have UNCHECKED
->Advanced
  -> NAT
      ->

->Advanced
  -> NAT
      -> Disable NAT Reflection for 1:1 NAT

I have CHECKED
->Advanced
  -> NAT
      -> Automatically create outbound NAT rules which assist inbound NAT rules that direct traffic back out to the same subnet it originated from.

I have tried deleting the 1:1 NAT to see if it would "create" the outbound NAT rules automatically.  No dice.  I've tried rebooting different times in between steps.  No dice.

I don't know what to check or how to proceed further with this.

What am I missing, what can I change, or how can I further debug this?

Thanks!

[caldwell]

(ping)

Anybody?

[Supermule]

Download snapshot from 18 jan 02:47.

It was the first beta that worked for me regarding NAT reflection….