One Way Pings Only
Host 172.16.10.3 can ping to the 172.16.1.0 subnet but not vice-versa and I cannot seem to figure out why.
The route on PFSENSE1 (furthest to the right) is pointing to 172.16.10.1 when I believe it should be pointing to 172.16.10.2.
Using RIP routing. Tried with static routes and it always seems to put that route in there [172.16.10.0/27 172.16.10.1]
Any ideas? Not sure if it is a firewall or routing issue but firewall rules are logical and should work fine.
First, what gateway did you set for WAN on pfsense1? You are correct in thinking it should be 10.2 as that is the next gateway in getting to the internet.
from LAN on pfsense1 to 172.16.10.3, should just be one hop. This is because 10.3 is on the same subnet as 10.1 (pfsense1).