BGP daemon that works with RADIX_MPATH / ECMP in FreeBSD-HEAD
-
Given some of the recent feedback regarding problems with using BGP under pfSense, I thought the following discussion in the freebsd-net mailing list might be of interest:
Looking for a bgp listener that works with RADIX_MPATH / EQMP that's in HEAD
Peter Wemm peter at wemm.org
Sat Jun 29 20:56:23 UTC 2013On Sat, Jun 29, 2013 at 1:42 PM, Hiroki Sato <hrs at="" freebsd.org="">wrote:
Peter Wemm <peter at="" wemm.org="">wrote
in <cage5ycptjkoezdckgu6qc_fvmnrbpnp4bizp0fyi5oyxk1dguw at="" mail.gmail.com="">:pe> I'm looking for pointers to something that can listen to bgp default
pe> route announcements from two outbound gateways and set a RADIX_MPATH
pe> compatible default route based on whether one or both are alive.
pe>
pe> openbgpd from ports is extremely incompatible with RADIX_MPATH on 10.
pe> You have to turn off fib (kernel routing table) updates or it will
pe> destroy your machine when it runs out of physical memory for duplicate
pe> routes.
pe>
pe> I know I can do an evil hack and poll the 'bgp show …' output and
pe> manually update the default route but that means updates are delayed
pe> to the poll interval. I'm hoping there is a more elegant solution
pe> that already works and is immediately responsive to a change in bgp
pe> state.
pe>
pe> The caveat is it must run on 10.x, with RADIX_MPATH enabled. I'd
pe> gladly run openbgpd if it actually worked. openbgpd has some
pe> awareness of mpath so it might be fixable but openbsd's multipath is
pe> different to ours.
pe>
pe> Ideas?Unfortunately openbgpd does not work well with RADIX_MPATH yet. As
you pointed out, it is due to difference of multiple routes support
between FreeBSD and OpenBSD. I think FIB handling can be improved,
but needs some more investigation for that.Yes, the port is extremely dangerous if RADIX_MPATH is enabled. It
does this sort of thing:cmd = RTM_ADD
retry:
error = routectl(cmdl, data);
if (error && cmd == RTM_ADD) {
cmd = RTM_CHANGE;
goto retry;
}In short, it creates duplicates every single time there's a fib change
if you enable RADIX_MPATH. This does not end well.It appears that openbsd allows multiple overlapping routes to coexist
if they have a MPATH flag on them. Our radix structure is quite
different from what I understand, but the routing socket interface
causes openbgpd to accidently work and spam the rables.I think Quagga and BIRD can work with injecting ECMP routes into
RADIX_MPATH-enabled FIB.– Hiroki
I'm looking for some examples. See the bgpd.conf fragments I sent Scott.
http://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-net/2013-June/035866.html</cage5ycptjkoezdckgu6qc_fvmnrbpnp4bizp0fyi5oyxk1dguw></peter></hrs>
Scott Long scott4long at yahoo.com
Sat Jun 29 20:28:32 UTC 2013We run bird for this task. Can't say if it works on 10 since he haven't
moved to 10 yet, but there have been some experiments with running
a 10 kernel in the 9 userland and bird seems to behave fine with that.Scott
http://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-net/2013-June/035863.html
So it seems that bird http://www.freshports.org/net/bird/ might be the answer …
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register LoginPrivacy Policy · Cookie Policy