New low power build (which cpu)
-
Celeron G1610 or Atom 2550 board? Which one would perform better?
Still recommending to stay away from Haswell chips?
-
Celeron G1610 or Atom 2550 board? Which one would perform better?
Still recommending to stay away from Haswell chips?
The G1610 is considerably faster.
If you are willing to run a prerelease build of 2.1.1 (currently reasonably stable, I'm running it at home and on a CARP backup at work) then Haswell is fine. I would not suggest it with 2.1.
-
Appreciate the response.
As for 2.1.1-Pre, how stable is it at this point? This isn't going into a production environment or anything commercial, but if it tanks, a couple people around me won't be happy. ::) -
Two thumbs up on the G1610 Passmarks and Price…..
But a 55 watt CPU just for a firewall is a bit excessive given its just for home use.
I would hunt down a lower wattage CPU for around the same price.
http://ark.intel.com/
http://ark.intel.com/products/family/43521/Intel-Celeron-Processor/desktopGood guide to find general performance values of various hardware.
http://www.cpubenchmark.net/ -
There are a couple decent deals on ebay as well right now
http://www.ebay.com/itm/BRAND-NEW-ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-A1-MAIN-BOARD-With-I3-CPU-AND-8GB-MEM-/111264859820?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item19e7e706ac
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Advantech-aimb-270-i3-330m-8gb-combo-mini-itx-mobile-qm57-/171220932079?pt=US_Motherboard_CPU_Combos&hash=item27dd9015ef
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-01-Mini-ITX-Motherboard-Intel-Core-w-8gb-RAM-and-i3-CPU-/290957780124?pt=BI_Control_Systems_PLCs&hash=item43be6f649c
I have 4 x AIMB-272 boards on the way. Those are 270's but still nice. Dual intel nic and mobile processors.
-
Another vote for the G1610.
There have been some posts to suggest that the G1610 doesn't in fact use much more power that the G1610T under low load conditions. It may not be worth the extra cost of the low power variants.I'm running 2.1.1 on a couple of test machines here with no issues. Unless you are planning some unusually exotic configuration you shouldn't have much to worry about. Even if you do have problems there are new snapshots with bugs fixes daily and you'll be helping to test. :)
You haven't said what bandwidth you are hoping to push through the box or what packages you're planning to run.
Steve
-
There are a couple decent deals on ebay as well right now
http://www.ebay.com/itm/BRAND-NEW-ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-A1-MAIN-BOARD-With-I3-CPU-AND-8GB-MEM-/111264859820?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item19e7e706ac
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Advantech-aimb-270-i3-330m-8gb-combo-mini-itx-mobile-qm57-/171220932079?pt=US_Motherboard_CPU_Combos&hash=item27dd9015ef
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-01-Mini-ITX-Motherboard-Intel-Core-w-8gb-RAM-and-i3-CPU-/290957780124?pt=BI_Control_Systems_PLCs&hash=item43be6f649c
Only if you don't mind the noise coming from a 6000+ RPM fan just to keep the CPU below 50c while idle. Also be aware that there is a mini-pcie port on the backside that makes quite difficult to find an adequate case. I have to add plastic washers to the mb's standoff, use larger screws and forget about the I/O shield for a while.
-
@ Steve
Could you list the configurations of the systems you have running the G1610 series and do a Kill-Watt check and report back?–------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The die size for all are the same.... All spec's are the same except for the clocks..... Transistor count should also be the same.
G1630 2.8 GHz 55w
G1620 2.7 GHz 55w
G1610 2.6 GHz 55w
G1620T 2.4 GHz 35w
G1610T 2.3 GHz 35whttp://ark.intel.com/products/family/43521/Intel-Celeron-Processor/desktop
Did did they turn off something in the CPU for the T's or is it just the clocks affecting power consumption?
Maybe the voltage is lower and better silicon for the T's?
Utilizing Power-D this will affect the power efficiency of the CPU's it would be nice to have some test data.
Will they all perform the same for they all would be clocked the same running under Power-D?
–------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The J Series at 10w look rather interesting. Will have to see the Passmarks once they get published on http://www.cpubenchmark.net/.
-
There are a couple decent deals on ebay as well right now
http://www.ebay.com/itm/BRAND-NEW-ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-A1-MAIN-BOARD-With-I3-CPU-AND-8GB-MEM-/111264859820?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item19e7e706ac
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Advantech-aimb-270-i3-330m-8gb-combo-mini-itx-mobile-qm57-/171220932079?pt=US_Motherboard_CPU_Combos&hash=item27dd9015ef
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-01-Mini-ITX-Motherboard-Intel-Core-w-8gb-RAM-and-i3-CPU-/290957780124?pt=BI_Control_Systems_PLCs&hash=item43be6f649c
Only if you don't mind the noise coming from a 6000+ RPM fan just to keep the CPU below 50c while idle. Also be aware that there is a mini-pcie port on the backside that makes quite difficult to find an adequate case. I have to add plastic washers to the mb's standoff, use larger screws and forget about the I/O shield for a while.
Maybe standoff washers depending on if your standoffs are set on islands or not. Usually they are. Why on earth would you need a 6000+ RPM fan to keep a mobile processor <45w tdp below 50c while idle?. Makes zero sense.
-
Appreciate the response.
As for 2.1.1-Pre, how stable is it at this point? This isn't going into a production environment or anything commercial, but if it tanks, a couple people around me won't be happy. ::)It should run fine.
If you want to go Haswell, I've tested 2.1 release on the Gigabyte H87M-D3H and Asrock H87M-Pro4 and they run fine. For the AsRock board, you'll need to set the SATA controller to AHCI and the i210 NIC will not work with 2.1 (2.1.1P has the updated drivers for it). The 8111F on the Gigabyte board runs fine with the realtek drivers in pfSense 2.1.
I imagine there aren't going to be much issues with the Haswell platform other than potentially unsupported onboard NICs (with pfSense 2.1.1P, this is probably limited to boards using 8111G & Atheros Attansic NICs).
-
@ Steve
Could you list the configurations of the systems you have running the G1610 series and do a Kill-Watt check and report back?I don't have any to report I'm afraid.
I'm sure there's extensive documentation somewhere about the differences between the standard and low voltage types but yes I exepect they are selected good silicon that can run at a lower voltage. It's probably a number of factors. Just remember that the TDP is simply the maximum power the package is designed to dissipate. It's useful when calculating how much cooling you will need but doesn't necessarily reflect the low load power consumption.Steve
-
Did did they turn off something in the CPU for the T's or is it just the clocks affecting power consumption?
Maybe the voltage is lower and better silicon for the T's?
Utilizing Power-D this will affect the power efficiency of the CPU's it would be nice to have some test data.
Will they all perform the same for they all would be clocked the same running under Power-D?
The T's, at least in that range, are simply clocked slower and have lower operating voltage.
As to Power-D, clock for clock, they will perform the same. However, EIST affects VID so it is likely that a T chip will consume less power at lower-loads and perhaps about the same at near idle - silicon limits of how just how low you can get. Not to mention, issues with digital logic threshold mismatches with the memory and PCH.
-
There are a couple decent deals on ebay as well right now
http://www.ebay.com/itm/BRAND-NEW-ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-A1-MAIN-BOARD-With-I3-CPU-AND-8GB-MEM-/111264859820?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item19e7e706ac
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Advantech-aimb-270-i3-330m-8gb-combo-mini-itx-mobile-qm57-/171220932079?pt=US_Motherboard_CPU_Combos&hash=item27dd9015ef
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ADVANTECH-AIMB-270-01-Mini-ITX-Motherboard-Intel-Core-w-8gb-RAM-and-i3-CPU-/290957780124?pt=BI_Control_Systems_PLCs&hash=item43be6f649c
Only if you don't mind the noise coming from a 6000+ RPM fan just to keep the CPU below 50c while idle. Also be aware that there is a mini-pcie port on the backside that makes quite difficult to find an adequate case. I have to add plastic washers to the mb's standoff, use larger screws and forget about the I/O shield for a while.
Maybe standoff washers depending on if your standoffs are set on islands or not. Usually they are. Why on earth would you need a 6000+ RPM fan to keep a mobile processor <45w tdp below 50c while idle?. Makes zero sense.
Ask the manufacturer, there is no way to control the fan speed on the AIMB-270 and it gets quite hot. I have 4 and all of them behave the same way. And TDP tells you how much heat the cooling system must able dissipate to keep the CPU under operating temperatures. Such small heatsink needs a fast fan to do the job.
-
Did did they turn off something in the CPU for the T's or is it just the clocks affecting power consumption?
Maybe the voltage is lower and better silicon for the T's?
Those are more like marketing tiers/worst case scenario than hard specs.
Case in point, here are some "55W" cpus.
Take a long hard look at the clock speeds, cache sizes and even gpu configuration.
Those all come off the same wafers and they selectively disable things so they can sell multiple models, binning isn't that magical. (some might be from partially defective chips, but by all accounts they aren't hurting much these days)
-
there is no way to control the fan speed on the AIMB-270
True there is not a way as far as I can tell on the AIMB-270. This doesn't stop you from adding a passive reducer, changing the fan or changing the cooler.
and it gets quite hot.
How hot are you talking? What power management setting are you using in the bios? Espescially at idle it shouldn't be very hot.
I have 4 and all of them behave the same way.
What CPU's are you using? I have a I7-620M running in my laptop on my desk and I can't hear it except when I pin it at 100% for long periods. It uses the cooler attached below shared with a dedicated videocard and the intel chipset.
-
50c idle, ~60c under load.
-
50c idle, ~60c under load.
These boards are ment to be hidden away serving signage or other industrial applications. Hence the high rpm fan. Are you sure you have power management set to: Power Efficient? If it is set to something else Speed Step may be disabled. Your load versus idle temperature is only a 10c difference. These processors are safe 80+ but I would rather keep under <75 full load in the summer. They may start throttling above that. With a new fan, new heatsink or just a fanspeed reducer there should not be a problem with noise.
Just like with every build if you want quiet you may have to replace a fan, lower the voltage to the fan or replace the heatsink.
-
I live in the Caribbean, summer is all year long. I am planning to mod a cooler for the i7 board and leave the i3 the way it is, I will probably use it to replace my demo pc.
-
-
I live in the Caribbean, summer is all year long. I am planning to mod…
Get one of them high horsepower large cockroaches in the wheel running that thing, cheap on power and an abundance of them down there ;)
