Accessing pfSense and multiple VMs running https on port 443

[mexscrabbler]

Hi,

First time user here, I tried searching the archives but have not been able to find anything that addresses my concern, apologies in advance if it has already been covered.

I have an ESXi (VMWARE) server hosting a pfSense VM and several other VM's, each of which is running a server I would like to access with https. The ESXI Server is accessed via a single external IP address, e.g. "SERVER_IP".

I don't mind having to use a different substitute port in the external addressing, e.g.:

<server_ip>:443    ==> <pfsense vm="">:443
<server_ip>:20443 ==> <vm1>:443
<server_ip>:20444 ==> <vm2>:443
<server_ip>:20445 ==> <vm3>:443

However, I can only get this to work for pfSense and one (1) VM. When I try a second or third VM, I get a timeout.

I've also tried it this way:

<server_ip>:20443 ==> <pfsense vm="">:443
<server_ip>:443    ==> <vm1>:443

With the same result. Other than pfSense and 1 VM, I cannot access subsequent VM's.

Any ideas what might be going on or how to troubleshoot it?

Thanks!</vm1></server_ip></pfsense></server_ip></vm3></server_ip></vm2></server_ip></vm1></server_ip></pfsense></server_ip>

[KOM]

https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/Port_Forward_Troubleshooting

https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/Firewall_Rule_Troubleshooting

Post screenshots of your NAT rules (port forward specifically) and WAN firewall rules.

[johnpoz]

So these other vms are behind th pfsense vm? The way i see your drawing pfsense is just another vm?

[mexscrabbler]

Hi KOM and johnpoz,

thanks for responding. I'm attaching a diagram of my setup as well as a screenshot of the NAT and WAN firewall rules.

I'm accessing the pfSense VM at <ip>:20443 and the IDRAC at <ip>:443

I would like to access other VM's (e.g. VM X and VM Y in diagram) at <ip>:443, and this is the part I can't get to work.

I cannot change the https port on VM X and VM y.

Any thoughts appreciated.

</ip></ip></ip>

[johnpoz]

so your running all your vms on the vmkern network? (mgmt lan) ??  The idrac is its own physical interface is in not?