Default gateway possible bug

[maverick_slo]

Hi!

SItuation:
I have 2 GW`s, DHCP (selected as default) and PPPoE.
I have Default gateway switching CHECKED.

Test:
Default GW is DHCP. I start a bunch of torrents, wait until DHCP GW is offline, pfSense switches to PPPoE gateway. So far so good.

I exit torrent client and DHCP gateway becomes online again. pfSense however does not always switch back to DHCP default GW.
So default GW remains PPPoE which is NOT OK.

ANy idea?

[maverick_slo]

Logs from the moment DHCP GW becomes available and dpinger shows it is warning packetloss (si it should be useable)

Apr 5 11:40:17 	php-fpm 	30118 	/rc.filter_configure_sync: Default gateway down setting PPPOE_PPPOE as default!
Apr 5 11:40:16 	xinetd 	20614 	Reconfigured: new=0 old=1 dropped=0 (services)
Apr 5 11:40:16 	xinetd 	20614 	readjusting service 6969-udp
Apr 5 11:40:16 	xinetd 	20614 	Swapping defaults
Apr 5 11:40:16 	xinetd 	20614 	Starting reconfiguration
Apr 5 11:40:16 	php-fpm 	30118 	/rc.filter_configure_sync: Default gateway down setting PPPOE_PPPOE as default!
Apr 5 11:40:15 	php-fpm 	30118 	/rc.openvpn: OpenVPN: One or more OpenVPN tunnel endpoints may have changed its IP. Reloading endpoints that may use WAN_DHCP.
Apr 5 11:40:15 	php-fpm 	30118 	/rc.dyndns.update: Default gateway down setting PPPOE_PPPOE as default!
Apr 5 11:40:14 	check_reload_status 		Reloading filter
Apr 5 11:40:14 	check_reload_status 		Restarting OpenVPN tunnels/interfaces
Apr 5 11:40:14 	check_reload_status 		Restarting ipsec tunnels
Apr 5 11:40:14 	check_reload_status 		updating dyndns WAN_DHCP 

[maverick_slo]

Should I file a bug?
Can someone else confirm this behaviour?

[cmb]

So it always switches the default gateway from the DHCP WAN to the PPPoE WAN when the DHCP WAN fails, but when it recovers it doesn't switch it back?

[maverick_slo]

Correct.

[athurdent]

Tried it with two static WANs, no problem there. Switches back to WAN1 as it should.

[maverick_slo]

Funny thing is, that it works sometimes :)
I tried 5 times and it failed 2 times.
Next try 5 times 1 time only didn't switch…

[maverick_slo]

Umm yeah, this is definitly a problem, now confirmed on 2 boxes.
See attached image.

[cmb]

There is something to that with PPP gateways. I'll look at it at some point past release. It's much better than it was in every version with apinger.

[maverick_slo]

Cool, should I file bug or.. ?

[maverick_slo]

https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/6110

Created a redmine ticket.

[jimp]

I tested this quite a bit with multiple PPPoE gateways and it was good there 100% of the time, though I don't think I tested it specifically with DHCP WAN1 + PPPoE WAN2.

You can try reversing my change in commit 2efb39d092a971c6ea8d06b25c315be7d400c4a1 to see if that helps.

[maverick_slo]

Someone just updated ticket, I'm sure I'm not alone :)