Trying to get VoIP Shaper correct BETA3

[kwag]

Hi sullrich and hoba,

Thanks  for your replies :)
I finally figured out what was happening.
First of all, I did a factory default, and then proceeded to run the Shaping Wizard once again.
After that, I noticed exactly the same problem, and I decided to do a tcpdump -vvv host MyTargetHost to get more info, and there I saw the problem!
My downstream was ToS=0x18 and my upstream was ToS=0x10  :o
However, I believe there's a bug in the matching rules, because look what happens below.

For example, this works fine:

lowdelay    yes    no      don't care
throughput yes    no    don't care
reliability   yes    no    don't care
congestion yes    no    don't care

But this, or any other combination that includes more than one tos value, will  bomb:

lowdelay    yes    no    don't care
throughput yes    no    don't care
reliability   yes    no    don't care
congestion yes    no    don't care

PF will complain as to the syntax and skip the rule of the offending line when trying to add tos=lowdelay,throughput, etc., on the same line.

So I just fixed the ToS on my Asterisk box to tos=0x18, selected lowdelay yes - on the "IP Type of Service (TOS)", and bingo!, upstream/downstream are now showing a nice red line while any phone is in use ;)

BUT, the question still is, shouldn't 0x10 match? Because it doesn't!  ???
Isn't 0x10 = lowdelay? or do I have it all wrong?

Thanks,
-Karl