ATT Uverse RG Bypass (0.2 BTC)
-
I haven't implemented pfsense yet, but under sophos utm it pulls an ip via dhcp within seconds.
Maybe pfsense has some advance options for dhcp that need to be adjusted?
Is your pfsense running baremetal or as a vm?
-
baremetal
-
I've been following this thread with a lot of interest - I also have AT&T fiber 1gbit/1gbit and would love to bypass the RG unit with pfSense hardware.
I agree we're getting very close, and the remaining issue is VLAN0 support under FreeBSD.
I'm not capable of doing much dev in this area, although I have a Netgate SG-3100 and would be happy to assist with testing.
I also have an older Netgate APU4 pfSense hardware router. If it is useful to anyone working on this solution, I would be happy to mail it to you - just reply or email me.
I just tried the dumb switch method this evening and got it working with netgear gs105. However, I had to statically assign my IP to the pfsense WAN, it wouldn't pull anything with DHCP. What am I doing wrong? I'm assuming when the lease expires its going to try to re-auth and i'll lose the connection? My main switch is a procurve 2800 48port. I tried Tagging 3 ports with the same VLAN ID and the modem wouldn't AUTH at all going through there.
You have to set your pfSense wan Mac to the Att RG MAC.
-
I've been following this thread with a lot of interest - I also have AT&T fiber 1gbit/1gbit and would love to bypass the RG unit with pfSense hardware.
I agree we're getting very close, and the remaining issue is VLAN0 support under FreeBSD.
I'm not capable of doing much dev in this area, although I have a Netgate SG-3100 and would be happy to assist with testing.
I also have an older Netgate APU4 pfSense hardware router. If it is useful to anyone working on this solution, I would be happy to mail it to you - just reply or email me.
I just tried the dumb switch method this evening and got it working with netgear gs105. However, I had to statically assign my IP to the pfsense WAN, it wouldn't pull anything with DHCP. What am I doing wrong? I'm assuming when the lease expires its going to try to re-auth and i'll lose the connection? My main switch is a procurve 2800 48port. I tried Tagging 3 ports with the same VLAN ID and the modem wouldn't AUTH at all going through there.
You have to set your pfSense wan Mac to the Att RG MAC.
Please see my previous post – this is the steps i took.
"I set my pfsense wan interface MAC to the same as the rgw and left as DHCP. I plug the rgw and ONT in the netgear switch. Let the broadband light go solid green, then unplug the RGW and plug the pfsense WAN nic in. pfsense WAN stays 0.0.0.0, never pulled an IP. So i tried it a 2nd time but used Static and that worked."
-
I have the same issue, cloned mac set to DHCP and only get 0.0.0.0. setting a static IP works. I wanted to set it up as dhcp because I think that is what's required to stop the 14 day de-auth issue?
-
Same reason i'm trying to use DHCP, but nothing. Just tried it again yesterday evening, tried disabling, restarting the WAN interface.
-
If you have a spare hd, try installing opnsense or sophos utm. I'm running the latter which is able to acquire ip via dhcp without issue. Same with using an asus rt-ac68u router (by spoofing mac).
-
If i'm changing OS, its going to be because the EAP_PROXY works without swapping cables.
-
I purchased a gs105ev2 to do the vlan flop and instantly pulled an IP via DHCP. Now I just have to figure out how to get DHCP6 working so I can use ipv6 too.
-
so DHCP doesn't work with a dumb switch then. its the vlan tagging playing part of it.
-
I'm using a dumb switch. DHCP works with it.
-
Random003 With pfsense?
I tried both pfsense and opnsense with a dumb switch. Was unsuccessful getting it to pull an ip. No issues with utm or an asus router and dumb switch. So it's something with pfsense and opnsense too as that didn't pull it either. I'd say the mac is getting spoofed because when set statically there is internet connectivity.
The dslr thread points to vlan priority being set. Maybe that has something to do with it.
-
Yes with pfsense version 2.4.2-RELEASE-p1 (amd64).
I'm spoofing the mac. The rest of the wan settings are default I think.
https://imgur.com/a/5qla4UI
-
^^How odd. What nic is your wan interface using? Mine was intel based (igb), specifically the i340-t4 card (in pci passthrough mode with exsi).
I think it would be useful to figure out why the dumb switch method works for some but not others with pfsense. What I didn't try was using the same nic as a virtual (vmxnet3) adapter.
-
NIC is Intel 82574L. I run pfsense on bare metal. I think the switch is a HP Procurve 1410-16G.
-
I don't think thats a dumb switch. I'm running my pfsense on a supermicro atom board with onboard intel nics, baremetal. Only set the spoofed mac on the WAN, and IP to dhcp using a netgear GS105. Nothing I did got DHCP to pull an IP, minute i statically assign a WAN IP, its fine.
I do have a Procurve 2848 managed switch, I was going to try taking 3 ports on there and creating a VLAN to try but guessing i'd have to move all the ports off the default VLAN 1?
-
@All
If you are trying to use the "dumb switch" method you can't use any REAL switch. Apparently the 802.1D standard doesn't pass 802.1x packets and will drop them.
Some reported and tested switches are as follows:
TL-SG2008 (I personally used this until about a month ago when I started to experience packet loss and other issues forcing me to be PassThrough on the AT&T RG itself)
GS108Ev3 (Reported by others with success)All of this knowledge and information comes from a MASSIVE thread at http://www.dslreports.com/forum/r29903721-AT-T-Residential-Gateway-Bypass-True-bridge-mode if you folks haven't read it yet.
-
This thread originally was for getting the eap_proxy working on pfsense. Has that just been given up on? It would really be nice if we could get a hands-off method working.
-
How do you figure the dumb switch method works with other firewall such as sophos utm, or even a basic rtac68u router, but not pfsense for some?
-