@Gertjan:
@PeterITG:
…..
With Pfsense the user has to connect then browse to a Http:// Site to get redirected.
When launching a https://…. you will NOT get redirected.
That's what https is all about.
Modern OS's (Windows, iOS, MacOS, etc) launch a hidden http://portal.microsoft.com or http://portal.apple.com or ...) when a Wifi connection is established. When the reply is redirected, a browser will open that shows you the "reply" : the portal login page.
I'm using pfSense in a hotel (read : NON-initiad clients end users). No one come down to the reception asking me why they can't acces sthe Internet. They will see the pfSense login page, they will hunt down the access password in mentioned on the papers present in their room, and they connect.
I never used "Antlabs Inngate, Nomadix, ValuePoint, and Unifi Ubiquiti". These are also "free-ware" solution ?
Yes I had allowed my DNS servers through the captive portal. So it was resolving the hidden OS checks so the captive portals weren't starting. So they weren't really being redirected till they tried a http site and most sites are https now. Our support know to have them try a http site but i knew something was wrong when it wasn't opening automatically.
Also those other devices are hospitality gateways that have the splash page, Integrate with a PMS system. Charged Tiered Bandwidth.