PPPOE wan will not connect -
-
@gerryatric Hi. The EM2 interface was a test or dummy. EM1 is the Wan. I have re added the correct photos. can you look at it now?
-
-
@fireodo there are 3 attached snips back up the post before your first reply. I removed the original and added 3 new ones. I can see them in the post.
-
I allready reloaded the site and in the photo I see your PPPOE0 is bound on em0.
After creating a VLAN on em0 you should have a new interface em0.2 - on this new created interface you have to bound your PPPOE0 ! -
Yup, that. Your wan assignment needs to show:
PPPOE0(em0.2)It needs to be on VLAN2 on em0.
Steve
-
Saw them.
I agree with @firedo :
The VLAN.2 interfaces is based on em0.
You have selected WAN = em0 as the PPPOE interface. Now, I'm don't know why you would have to use a VLAN for a PPPoE connection, but as you mentioned it, I presume the PPPoE goes over VLAN.2 that goes over WAN.If the em0 interface is physically connected to the PPPOE "modem", and you have instructions from your ISP that you need a "VLAN tagged "2" then :
Create the VAN.2 interface :
Assign this VLAN.2 interface :
I gave it the name "OPT3theVLAN2overWAN".
You have to assign it, to be able to use it.
No need to change or add set any settings here :
OPT3theVLAN2overWANNow, on the PPPoE tab :
You saw I selected the VLAN.2 interface - not the parent em0 interface ?
Btw : I'm not using PPPoE any more. I did so in the past, but I didn't need to create a VLAN to make it work. My PPPoE was 'based or 'watched' to the WAN directly.
-
Hi all and thanks so much for the explanations. It is a little confusing that I didn't get it straight away .
The reason I have to use a vlan is that my provider assigns vlan id 2 to my fibre connection on their NTD.
They said I have to insert this into my vlan.
which I currently have on my Unifi USG pro 4 and all is working well there.
But I want to use PFSENSE as there is a known speed issue with the unifi gear and things like Intrusion detection prevention chops the outside speed throughput in half and some other things. so instead of getting close to 1GBps performance I end up with about 300mbps on a good day. -
Just for my own curiosity : which ISP / Country ?
-
@gertjan hi. It is Australia and IINET is the provider. yes we are a bit slow downunder with our NBN. I am luck to be able to get fibre. most of the country is on copper still and won't change for a very long time
-
@gerryatric ok I have set this as per the photos left by @Gertjan
I am still getting a Wan down link
-
The last image :
You should not select the WAN interface to activate PPPoE on it.
You should select OPT1 interface - your second image - (which is a VLAN over WAN) and select PPPoe on that OPT1 interface.See this video for a classic PPPoE set up on WAN.
Your setup is not using the WAN directly, but the derived VLAN.2 interface, which has WAN as a parent.The video is useful also as it show how to deal with the WAN interface itself, at it isn't a gateway any more.
-
@gertjan right so I get that. and now I have disabled the wan and enabled opti1
which now shows a green active arrow. awesome. It isn't showing an IP which it should as it is via DHCP. still showing 0.0.0.0
So still at a loss.
It is a pity in that video that he just has chequer board stuff all over the screen to stop people seeing his stuff. makes it hard to know what is going on really.Any ideas on the dhcp issue and no ip?
-
@gerryatric said in PPPOE wan will not connect -:
It isn't showing an IP which it should as it is via DHCP
It should be using PPPoE not DHCP as I understand it.
Check the PPP logs. If the PPPoE session is correctly using VLAN2 over the connected parent NIC then you should see something from the remote side. Even if that's an error coming back it at least tells us the connection is there.
Steve
-
@stephenw10 Steve Hi
The moment I change it from DHCP to PPPOE it fails the connection.
The wan as @Gertjan explained to me was to setup a PPPOE connection, do not use the EM0 interface but use the newly created interface with PPPOE with the Vlan tag 2 as per his message and I have done all that.
I get a green interface now, but no IP.
If I change that to PPPOE it creates a second PPPOE connection and it all goes red.Or am I missing something
My provider has me on PPPOE connection with user name and password, DHCP and a vlan tag of 2
It works simply on my unifi USG Pro 4 with just my username and password and the vlan tag in the box and straight away it comes up.
PFSense is obviously more configurable . and I may have missed a step. -
It isn't a DHCP connection, you need to use PPPoE.
When you set it to DHCP the green arrow is showing the link status which there is the link between em0 and the modem. Obviously that is good hence it shows green.
The PPP session is still down though and that's what counts.You can only have one PPPoE session on each parent interface so if you already created on on em0.2 you cannot assign something else to that.
Please show us the current Interfaces > Assignments configuration.
-
@stephenw10 here you go Stephen
-
Ok so the interface that you need is not assigned.
Re-assign WAN as PPPoE(em0.2).
Delete WANPPPOE unless you need that for modem access.
Steve
-
@stephenw10 boom. now it works.
See I was told to disable the wan port and use the newly created port with the PPPOE interface etc.
oh cool. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction -
It should be possible to do that. I think what you were hitting was that when you chnaged the connection type to PPPoE on the new interface, that was assigned as em0 VLAN2, you were effectively creating a 2nd PPPoE session on the same parent. And that is not allowed.
Deleting the original PPPoE session would probably also have worked. But it's 'cleaner' to have WAN assigned to the actual WAN connection IMO. So all good.
Steve
-
@stephenw10 Sadly stephen. it only lasted a few minutes with the IP from the provider and now it is back to Wan down.
I did not change anything. I actually left it and went and did some other stuff. came back and noticed it offline
no idea now
