How to set ip range on LAN same as WAN range ip
-
Yeah the examples you gave are not conflicting subnets so there's no problem assigning one as WAN and and one as LAN.
Is that not actually the case?Steve
-
@stephenw10
i have pfsense with ip address: 86.25.32.21
and my server is : 86.25.32.23
and gateways of pfsense and server is : 86.25.32.20
i have LAN interface on pfsense that when i trying to set ip 86.25.32.25 i get this error :
IPv4 address 86.25.32.25/32 is being used by or overlaps with: WAN (86.25.32.21/28)i have this problem.
my purpose is my server can not connect to internet directly and only can connect to internet through pfsense.
please help me -
@pflover said in How to set ip range on LAN same as WAN range ip:
i have LAN interface on pfsense that when i trying to set ip 86.25.32.25 i get this error :
IPv4 address 86.25.32.25/32 is being used by or overlaps with: WAN (86.25.32.21/28)That might be true. 86.25.32.25 is part of the WAN network 86.25.32.21/28, so you cannot use this IP on LAN.
The only option to use a public IP out out of the WAN network behind pfSense is bridging the interface as described in the docs.
-
Yup, that^. In that situation you can only use bridged interfaces.
-
Bridging is not the only way - he could just nat it and use a vip for whatever public IP he wants to use and either port forward the specific ports he needs or 1:1 nat
Which would be far easier and less complex setup than a bridge - and less likely for a security screw up if using port forwards.
-
Yup that's true if the server doesn't require a public IP directly.
I'd thought it did but reading back now it's not clear. -
@stephenw10 said in How to set ip range on LAN same as WAN range ip:
server doesn't require a public IP directly.
It would be a very odd scenario where it HAD to be public.. Like some license hard locked to having to see public IP? I really can not think of a scenario that it wouldn't be better to just nat..
Unless there is a specific reason that public IP on the device is required - which can not think of.. Something needed with L2 from the isp maybe? Doubtful.
-
Unfortunately it's something we see quite often. Some server/application that will only use it's local IP with no way to be configured for an external public IP or detect it automatically.
I agree, it shouldn't ever happen in 2021 but.... -
@stephenw10 You mean like a ftp server handing out its IP to connect to via passive?
-
Yup, exactly like that. PBXs are also relatively common. Other more obscure appliances etc.
-
@stephenw10 that is just SAD at so many levels.
