Unable to game on xbox one for multi-player

droidus

This is the error message: "Your network is good, but there may be matchmaking issues.
Your NAT type is 'Strict'. If you're currently having trouble connecting to other players on Xbox multiplayer/matchmaking, try testing your NAT type again. If that doesn't help, try alternate port selection. Otherwise, if you're not having issues, you may continue."

droidus

Can anyone please assist me with this?

mcury

@droidus

Check if this can help you:

https://forum.netgate.com/topic/168376/multiple-xbox-consoles-with-open-nat-and-working-play-together/2

droidus

@mcury It didn't seem to work for me. So my setup is using LAN for main/personal stuff, then OPT1 is being used for games, etc. Does this change any of those instructions?
I can also post screenshots of each step as well.

mcury

@droidus Double checked and using OPT1 instead of LAN wouldn't change anything as far as I could observe..

@droidus said in Unable to game on xbox one for multi-player:

I can also post screenshots of each step as well.

Post your outbound NAT rules, I suspect you didn't put the static nat below your dynamic nat for the OPT1 network.

droidus

@mcury

mcury

@droidus It's not correct.

You need to put static first, then the dynamic.

1 - WAN - XboxOne XboxOne_Port - WAN address static
2 - WAN - XboxOne XboxOne_Port - WAN address dynamic

You don't need rule number 3, you can delete that.

droidus

@mcury OK, it (the xbox one) is saying the NAT type is Open now; Is that right?

mcury

@droidus Yes, if it's saying NAT Open, its probably working now.

mcury

@mcury said in Unable to game on xbox one for multi-player:

1 - WAN - XboxOne XboxOne_Port - WAN address static
2 - WAN - XboxOne XboxOne_Port - WAN address dynamic

There is an error in my post, should be like this:

1 - WAN - XboxOne XboxOne_Port * * WAN address static
2 - WAN - XboxOne * * * WAN address dynamic

But I guess you already corrected because you are getting NAT Open, can you confirm if everything is working now ?

I suppose you don't need rule number 2, as you are using Hybrid Outbound NAT, which would already create automatically, an outbound dynamic NAT for your OPT1 network.

droidus

@mcury Disabling the second rule gives me this message upon testing multiplayer connect: "It's all good There are no problems with your connection for multiplayer. If you're still having trouble, try testing your NAT type again. "
NAT detection returns Open still.
Thanks!