Multi-WAN gateway failover not switching back to tier 1 gw after back online

devmaybe

I think I have found a solution.

I have tested it on 2.3.2 release, it consists of 2 steps

Take note of the name you assigned to your PPPoE connection (WAN2 in this example)
Add the following lines at the end of "/usr/local/sbin/ppp-linkup" script (between "fi" and "exit 0" lines)

–-----------------------
fi

sleep 5
/etc/rc.newwanip wan2

exit 0

In all my tests traffic switches back correctly.

Note: without the "sleep" instructions I was having mixed results, maybe is only a timing problem with pppoe activation?

Bye

SecureIS

+1 that failback would be very valuable. I have a deployment where the Tier 2 connection is pay per GB so it would be nice to be able to automate failover AND failback but I have to keep that WAN disconnected to make sure no connections get stuck on it. It's not a PPPoE link so sadly I can't use an up/down script for this :(

We need a setting for "Flush all states when a lower tier gateway comes back up. The monitoring process will flush all states when a lower tier gateway comes up if this box is checked"

luckman212

I'm working on a script to kill VOIP states when WAN1 (primary) comes back online. As mentioned elsewhere in this thread, this is a critical feature in real-world scenarios due to (a) costly metered backup connections as well as (b) SIP interop issues when devices behind the same LAN are seen registering from different public IPs. So I won't rehash all of that. I am trying to automate pfctl from the rc.gateway_alarm script that gets called on WANUP. I also see that a PR has been recently merged that might help make this even easier and less hacky. Has anyone hooked into these new functions yet to make this more reliable?

TL;DR— pfctl is not killing all of the related states. Can someone help me to understand something regarding states?

• Assume vlan100 is dedicated for voice, with subnet 192.168.20.0/24
• WAN1=primary, WAN2=backup
• When a "fail back" WAN2–>WAN1 event happens, I need to kill all states: (any)->WAN2->vlan100 and vlan100->WAN2->(any)
• I try using a command like:

pfctl -i igb0_vlan100 -k 0.0.0.0/0

But, this only seems to kill the states originating from inside the LAN. There are still tracked states via WAN2 that are NAT'ted to –> internal igb0_vlan100 IPs. Do I also need to run the commands like this instead?

pfctl -k 192.168.20.0/24 -k 0.0.0.0/0
pfctl -k 0.0.0.0/0 -k 192.168.20.0/24

Or, some other command? Is there a better way…. ???

nemanager

Any news ? :(

kimkhan

Failback to default WAN works for me.

I have a Gigabit Fiber connection and a Cable modem connection. I put one of them as Tier1 and the other as Tier2.

I used 8.8.8.8 for one and 8.8.4.4 for the other.

But just following all the instructions in pfsense documentation and postings here in the forum that suggests with creating groups and different level of Tiers and etc. will not work unless you have the 'Default gateway switching' box checked. You can find it under System > Advanced > Miscellaneous

http://prntscr.com/evn3ub

I tested with disconnecting WAN1 and going to whatismyip.com and then plugging WAN1 back and going to a different what is my ip site. Don't go to the first one as it will be cached and will not show your original/default wan IP.

Or you can just do a ping.

Let me know if this helps. I can also post my configurations if you need to see.

KK

red_cat1930

2.3.3-RELEASE-p1 (amd64), MultiWAN, VM on Hyper-V

WAN1 ( tier2, monitor ip 8.8.4.4 )
WAN2 ( tier1, monitor ip 8.8.8.8 ).

Today WAN2 had alarm latecy but no clear latency occured despite the fact line becomes stable (accordingly to dashboard)

Usual (System logs->Gateways):
Apr 12 03:29:32 dpinger WAN2_DHCP 8.8.8.8: Clear latency 39052us stddev 2978us loss 5%
Apr 12 03:28:34 dpinger WAN2_DHCP 8.8.8.8: Alarm latency 34409us stddev 429us loss 22%

Today (no clear latency event):
–-
Apr 13 13:19:23 dpinger WAN2_DHCP 8.8.8.8: Alarm latency 34494us stddev 342us loss 21%

All clients from from LAN were using WAN1 until i manually simulated WAN2 disconnect (set 1.1.1.1 as monitor ip for a minute, then revert back to 8.8.8.8 )

carmico

same problem here

failover is working tier1 to tier2, but when tier1 recovers, monitor says "online" but the traffic doesn't switch back to tier1 , remains on tier2

PFsense ver. 2.3.3-RELEASE-p1

ronnysa

@carmico:

same problem here

failover is working tier1 to tier2, but when tier1 recovers, monitor says "online" but the traffic doesn't switch back to tier1 , remains on tier2

PFsense ver. 2.3.3-RELEASE-p1

I am having the exact same problem here.

2.3.3-RELEASE-p1 (amd64)
built on Thu Mar 09 07:17:41 CST 2017
FreeBSD 10.3-RELEASE-p17

jono_white

The fail back seems to work providing the PC's connection is left idle for 20 Seconds or so, but if theres an active connection after your primary connection goes down (voip, video/audio streaming or even a continuous ping), it seems to remain on the redundant connection.

The following script seems to work for my situation (4g modem failover with limited quota), it's nowhere near perfect but it'll shut the 4g interface down long enough for the states to be killed when the Primary WAN is up , would be better if it exited if there was no active states on 4G but meh..

(Using cron to run every 5 minutes or so, */5 * * * * root /bin/sh /root/routercheck.sh)

#!/bin/sh

check_wan1=8.8.8.8
check_wan2=8.8.4.4

wan_ipaddress=ifconfig rl0 | grep 'inet ' | awk '{ print $2}' | cut -d'/' -f1
backupwan_ipaddress=ifconfig rl1 | grep 'inet ' | awk '{ print $2}' | cut -d'/' -f1

ping -c 2 -S {backupwan_ipaddress} ${check_wan2} > /dev/null 2>&1
wan2_resp=$?

backupwan_resp=expr ${wan2_resp}

if [ ${backupwan_resp} -gt 0 ]; then
exit 1
fi

ping -c 2 -S ${wan_ipaddress} ${check_wan1} > /dev/null 2>&1
wan1_resp=$?

wan_resp=expr ${wan1_resp}

if [ ${wan_resp} -eq 0 ]; then

#service netif restart rl1
ifconfig rl1 down;sleep 15;ifconfig rl1 up

fi

#end

eng1tx

@jono_white:

The fail back seems to work providing the PC's connection is left idle for 20 Seconds or so, but if theres an active connection after your primary connection goes down (voip, video/audio streaming or even a continuous ping), it seems to remain on the redundant connection.

The following script seems to work for my situation (4g modem failover with limited quota), it's nowhere near perfect but it'll shut the 4g interface down long enough for the states to be killed when the Primary WAN is up , would be better if it exited if there was no active states on 4G but meh..

(Using cron to run every 5 minutes or so, */5 * * * * root /bin/sh /root/routercheck.sh)

#!/bin/sh

check_wan1=8.8.8.8
check_wan2=8.8.4.4

wan_ipaddress=ifconfig rl0 | grep 'inet ' | awk '{ print $2}' | cut -d'/' -f1
backupwan_ipaddress=ifconfig rl1 | grep 'inet ' | awk '{ print $2}' | cut -d'/' -f1

ping -c 2 -S {backupwan_ipaddress} ${check_wan2} > /dev/null 2>&1
wan2_resp=$?

backupwan_resp=expr ${wan2_resp}

if [ ${backupwan_resp} -gt 0 ]; then
exit 1
fi

ping -c 2 -S ${wan_ipaddress} ${check_wan1} > /dev/null 2>&1
wan1_resp=$?

wan_resp=expr ${wan1_resp}

if [ ${wan_resp} -eq 0 ]; then

#service netif restart rl1
ifconfig rl1 down;sleep 15;ifconfig rl1 up

fi

#end

Thank you for this…

I am not a script writer, but it would appear I need to change rl0 and rl1 to my specific interfaces. Any other changes necessary?

Also, I have searched for a couple of hours and still cannot find what directory to install the script to, and what command to run at CLI to test. I see that the "Filer" pkg was the preferred way, but is no longer available on my version, 2.3.4.

jono_white

Yeah , it needs to be changed to the physical interface names, not the name assigned in pfsense. script location can be anywhere, i just saved mine under /root/failback.sh , you'll need to allow it to run after saving, chmod 775 scriptname.sh should do it, aslong as the path in your cron points to the script it can go anywhere,

Thinking it may be better to just leave the 4g interface down until the wan stops responding though, it may have a better outcome, but it still seems to do the job

jono_white

i've changed it so the 4g is down until the primary wan stops working, this time cron is set every minute, the most time you should lose connection is maybe 70 or 80 seconds or so as it takes some time for the gateway to register as online again

#!/bin/sh

check_wan1=8.8.8.8
#check_wan2=8.8.4.4

wan_ipaddress=ifconfig rl0 | grep 'inet ' | awk '{ print $2}' | cut -d'/' -f1
#backupwan_ipaddress=ifconfig rl1 | grep 'inet ' | awk '{ print $2}' | cut -d'/' -f1

#ping -c 2 -S {backupwan_ipaddress} ${check_wan2} > /dev/null 2>&1
#wan2_resp=$?

#backupwan_resp=expr ${wan2_resp}

#if [ ${backupwan_resp} -eq 1 ]; then
# exit 1

#fi

ping -c 2 -S ${wan_ipaddress} ${check_wan1} > /dev/null 2>&1
wan1_resp=$?

wan_resp=expr ${wan1_resp}

if [ ${wan_resp} -eq 0 ]; then

ifconfig rl1 down

fi

if [ ${wan_resp} -gt 0 ]; then

#service netif restart rl1
ifconfig rl1 up

fi

#end

David127

Hello.

I have a similar problem with failover. I use one openvpn client as tier1 and the second openvpn client as tier2.
After tier1 is online, pfsense does not switch back from tier2 to tier1.

Is the solution from kimkhan suitable for me? Any other solutions?

nemanager

Dear pfSense Staff, this is a very important issue, we can find a solution? :-)

David127

I have perhaps found my problem in pfSense 2.3.4.

My setup in System > Routing > Gateway Groups:

OpenVPN Client1 = tier1
OpenVPN Client2 = tier2

I have not set 'Default gateway switching' or anything else.

In System > Routing > Gateways I have set:

Monitor IP of OpenVPN Client1 = 8.8.8.8
Monitor IP of OpenVPN Client2 = 8.8.4.4

If I disable OpenVPN Client1, then pfsense switches to OpenVPN Client2 correctly.
But only after I have activated 'Apply Settings' in "System > Routing > Gateways"

If I activate OpenVPN Client1, then pfsense switches back to OpenVPN Client1.
But only after I have activated 'Apply Settings' in "System > Routing > Gateways" again.

Does somebody has any idea, which settings should I make?

lobi

I have the same issue with my failover WAN. If WAN1 goes down=Offline switching to WAN2 works correctly but it don't switch back to WAN1 if its available again. I have to deactivate and activate WAN1 manually.

Anyone have a solution?

I've set multi WAN as the screenshots below:

13:37 WAN1 goes offline
14:00 WAN1 is available again but don't switch back to WAN2

System Logs:

Feb 27 13:37:48 rc.gateway_alarm 91471 >>> Gateway alarm: WAN1GW (Addr:8.8.4.4 Alarm:1 RTT:18713ms RTTsd:4408ms Loss:22%)
Feb 27 13:37:48 check_reload_status updating dyndns WAN1GW
Feb 27 13:37:48 check_reload_status Restarting ipsec tunnels
Feb 27 13:37:48 check_reload_status Restarting OpenVPN tunnels/interfaces
Feb 27 13:37:48 check_reload_status Reloading filter
Feb 27 13:37:50 php-fpm 5341 /rc.dyndns.update: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 13:37:50 php-fpm 5341 /rc.dyndns.update: MONITOR: WAN1GW is down, omitting from routing group DualWAN 8.8.4.4|192.168.100.2|WAN1GW|18.747ms|4.479ms|25%|down
Feb 27 13:37:50 php-fpm 5341 /rc.dyndns.update: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 13:37:50 php-fpm 65471 /rc.openvpn: OpenVPN: One or more OpenVPN tunnel endpoints may have changed its IP. Reloading endpoints that may use WAN1GW.
Feb 27 13:37:50 php-fpm 65471 /rc.openvpn: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 13:37:50 php-fpm 65471 /rc.filter_configure_sync: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 13:40:20 php-fpm 11774 /services_dyndns.php: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 13:40:24 check_reload_status Syncing firewall
Feb 27 13:40:24 php-fpm 11697 /services_dyndns.php: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 14:11:47 check_reload_status Syncing firewall
Feb 27 14:11:47 check_reload_status Reloading filter
Feb 27 14:11:48 php-fpm 23963 /rc.filter_configure_sync: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 14:20:59 check_reload_status Syncing firewall
Feb 27 14:20:59 check_reload_status Reloading filter
Feb 27 14:21:00 php-fpm 34668 /rc.filter_configure_sync: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!
Feb 27 14:24:10 check_reload_status Syncing firewall
Feb 27 14:24:10 check_reload_status Reloading filter
Feb 27 14:24:11 php-fpm 5833 /rc.filter_configure_sync: Default gateway down setting WAN2_PPPOE as default!

Thanks

markn455

I am having a similar issue. However, I am unable to get it to work simply failing over from WAN1 to WAN2. The logs show that when WAN1 goes down the default it appears things switch. Whoever, traffic does not flow and the pfSense UI hangs (actually becomes very slow). Then Bringing WAN1 back on-line does to resume traffic flow. The quickest way to get things going again is to restart the box. I have configured the dual wan configuration in the simplest way similar to your. I have also tried the suggested configurations that does not use the automatic gateway switching building gateway groups in accordance with the configuration suggestions. I have tried using different hardware and rebuilding pfSense from scratch. The frustrating part for me is I can take a commercial firewall that supports multi-wan and configure things in a similar fashion and it works perfect every time. I apologize for not having a proven solution. You getting it to work this far is great. The only thing different is that many of the multi-wan configuration recommendations is that You have an additional gateway group that handles flipping connections back the other way.

This is one of many configuration examples out there https://www.cyberciti.biz/faq/howto-configure-dual-wan-load-balance-failover-pfsense-router/. I found this one to be helpful as most are. I think in my case it just my limited experience or perhaps I have a glaring simple issue preventing mine from working that I am just missing.

satadru

@markn455 Did you ever find a working configuration for failing back to a primary connection once it comes back up?

matronyx

Goal: Have auto fail-over to 2nd ISP when 1st ISP is down. When 1st ISP comes back, re-enable as primary in routes.
My ISP setup all use static ip config, have not tested with a dynamic interface.

Here is what works for me, various sites, multiple ISP fail-overs.

Step 1:
Navigate to: System - > Advanced -> Miscellaneous
Make sure "Default gateway switching" is UNCHECKED.

Step 2:
Configure your gateway group accordingly. Tier1 is highest priority.
I use Member Down as trigger.

Step 3:
Choose the gateway group in your firewall rules setup.
You find this under Advanced Options for each rule you want to make use of the gateway group.

Simple test if working, plug out Tier1 cable from firewall. Should fail-over to Tier2.
Plug back in Tier1 cable, should become the default route almost instantly.

satadru

@matronyx

Just for clarification:

Default gateway switching is unchecked.
A single gateway group with Tier 1 gateway being highest priority, and Tier 2 being lower priority, and member down is the trigger.
Firewall rules use that gateway group.

And that works for failover? If you pull the cord for gateway 1 it switches to gateway 2? And if you reconnect gateway 1 it switches back?