SG-1100 Throughput Test
-
I can't get more than 250 Mbps with a Vanilla install. Which version of pfSense are you running? Mine is 2.4.4
-
@JInx-IT plain vanilla pfsense latest version that was installed out of the box. 2.4.4-p2
-
You are correct. I have, however, heard that people running 2.3.* are getting gigabit speeds. I was wondering if it was a 2.4.* issue that was throttling me to around 250 Mpbs. If other people are getting Gigabit, or close, speeds in 2.4.*, I'd like to know what they are running and how it's configured. My gut says I have something misconfigured, but I don't have a clue what it would be. I was hoping I could compare between my setup and another person's who was getting at least closer to Gigabit speeds, with the same hardware.
-
@JInx-IT and what are your results with 2.4.4-p2 and what is your test environment?
-
Not sure what you're talking about since the SG-1100 was never supported by anything older than pfSense 2.4.4-p1.
-
Maybe he is confusing the SG-1100, with the 1000?
-
I've read posts from people claiming to be running an old Dell desktop with a couple of gigabit cards, running pfSense 2.3.*, getting in the high 990 Mbps. I can plug my laptop straight into the modem and get the same. High 990 Mbps, no problem. When I put the Netgate SG-1100 between my laptop and the modem, my speeds go down to 250 Mbps or lower.
-
@JInx-IT you installed 2.3 on a sg -1100?
-
@JInx-IT said in SG-1100 Throughput Test:
getting in the high 990 Mbps.
Nonsense - since not possible to get that on a gig interface... Do the math yourself..
-
That's with no traffic shaping or anything. It's just the basic setup.
-
Dude you have been show simple out of the box the SG-1100 doing high 800's if your only seeing 250ish you got something wrong with your testing method or your hardware in the path of your test.
You have yet to show your test method. Sorry but you aint going to see 990s on any gig interface. your going to be in the 940's as max..
Duplicate the testing that hbauer did above.
-
I never said I am running 2.3.*, I'm running what came on it, which is 2.4.4-p2. My question was, and still is, how to achieve Gigabit speeds with an SG-1100, when it looks like the hardware itself can't support anything more than 250 Mbps. I'm hoping I'm wrong, so I'm here looking for proof that I'm configuring something incorrectly. Why can my laptop to the modem get Gigabit speeds, but a basic config in the SG-1100 maxes out at 250 Mbps? The answer, I feel, is in looking at the differences between my configuration, and somebody's who has the correct config in their SG-1100, and by correct config, I mean somebody who is getting Gigabit speeds.
-
@JInx-IT I am just a netgate customer and I can confirm the results posted above. The hardware can do it without any changes to the standard config. I suggest to open another topic with more details about your modem. I suspect that there is a need for some changes.
-
Dude out of the box it will do gig speeds... You have been shown this and confirmed by multiple people..
Benchmarks are listed here as well
https://www.netgate.com/blog/netgates-new-sg-1100-punches-way-above-its-weight.html -
The modem is setup the way we have had things setup for the last 4 years worth of using a pfSense router, which we traditionally ran off of a SuperMicro system. Pretty much all of our clients are running one, and they aren't going much past 200 Mbps. When we went up to over 400 Mbps, we noticed the router was bottlenecking the speeds, because bypassing the router and running a laptop straight to the modem produced the advertised speeds. The same is holding true with the SG-1100. Doing a speedtest from the router maxes out at 250 Mbps, but taking the router out, and plugging the laptop directly into the modem, the laptop gets Gigabit speeds. What we need, is a router we can suggest to our clients that will get Gigabit speeds. The issue is, it looks like we will have to use some cast off desktops to get that going, instead of using a professional hardware package. What I'm hoping for is that I'm missing something in the config settings that is impeding the throughput. I would love to offer this box as a Gigabit solution.
-
@johnpoz So, are you saying that it's a defective SG-1100? Because, out of the box, it's not getting gig speeds. Not even close.
-
@JInx-IT Do you have a change to try my setup with iperf connected to a switch? If this is better then you know its a configuration thing. if not open a ticket at netgate
-
@JInx-IT said in SG-1100 Throughput Test:
it's not getting gig speeds. Not even close.
And you have yet to show you can actually do a valid test... Lets see your test method and showing that your client and server can actually talk doing gig, etc.
hbauer gave exacting details of testing done showing 880's
If after showing valid test methods and default config - then yeah open a support ticket.
Doing a speed test to some internet site with some client behind pfsense is NOT a valid test method.
-
What I use for speedtest from pfSense and any other Linux based platform is speedtest-cli. If that's not accurate enough, I am certainly open to new methods.
-
@JInx-IT If you are testing it from the firewall, that is not accurate. You need to test from a device behind the firewall to a public device on the other side.
