WAN not connecting with bridge modem rogers cable
-
If they both have the same gateway then you would not be able to route traffic to them differently. It's not really valid.
Steve
-
My gateway on pfsense is 99.246.124.1, but 99.246.150.1 on my 2nd connection, so they are completely separate subnets. Both have /23 subnet mask. The MTU on my 2nd connection is 1280, vs 1500 on pfsense.
-
As I mentioned, I used to be able to connect, but that failed with 2.6.0, IIRC. Ping works, but OpenVPN doesn't. However, it does if I tether to my cell phone.
Here's what I get when I try to connect via my 2nd connection. Similar would happen with ssh.
-
Hmm, that's between your two WANs somehow? I could definitely see that failing...
-
The thing is, it used to work, prior to 2.6.0. Those are 2 completely independent subnets. After I updated to 2.6.0, I wasted a lot of time trying to understand what was wrong with my configuration, until I realized I had done nothing wrong. It was pfsense or perhaps FreeBSD that failed.
-
Between 2 pfSense devices then?
Hard to see how that could have worked between two interfaces on the same device... -
Between pfsense and a notebook computer. I have a ThinkPad which I use for testing. It runs Linux and prior to pfsense I was also using Linux for a firewall. It worked then and after I moved to pfsense about 5.5 years ago, it continued to work. Then 2.6.0...
-
Hmm, I can't think of anything in 2.6 that would cause something like that.
If it come in on the WAN it will send replies back to the WAN gateway. There could be an issue with the ISP moving that traffic both ways over the link, assuming the gateway is at the ISP end.
There were some changes to that code in 2.5.X but 2.6 retains that.
Steve
-
Well, as I said, it worked before. The last time it did was just a couple of days before I updated. As the packet capture shows, the packets are getting through. I had a fair bit of discussion about this in the OpenVPN section just after 2.6.0 came out. Ping works, but I don't know enough about OpenVPN or ssh to take it further.
So, when I test, I now have to tether to my cell phone, when I didn't before.
-
Except it failed overnight, when I changed versions. As the capture shows, there are 2 gateways involved, so there should be no conflict that way and my cell phone is with the same company. I do recall there were some OpenVPN changes when this happened. I redid my config to accommodate them and also because I wasn't thrilled with what I had.
Correction, this came in with pfsense 2.5.0, not 2.6.0. I'm currently running 2.5.2. 2.5.0 came out on Feb. 17 and I was inquiring about the the OpenVPN version in openSUSE on Feb. 24, to see if that might be the cause of the problem.
