I set up a tunnel for a branch of mine that has pfsense too, but I can not have communication between them.
Check your Phase 2 & firewall rules.
I'd be using IKEv2 if you can.
Just happened to be playing earlier
also check Status / System log / IPsec on both pfsense and report eventually.
what does it say ?
i can't see anything wrong from your screenshot, it can be some mismatch on the other side like wrong ip on the remote gateway / wrong peer identifier
and again we don't see a phase2 for the other pfSense
first thing first we need to understand what's not working exactly from the log
I was off the ip sec service.
I can drip my public ip from the other base, but I can't drip my machine there
Not sure what you mean.
You may be better posting here:-