@SageIT:
I forgot to mention…my previous gateway, the one I'd like to replace with the pfsense box, is just an asus AC-rt66u router running dd-wrt. It has an ip address of 192.168.0.26, and all of my clients on the LAN are static IP's, pointing to that router (0.26) as the gateway, and to my primary DC for dns (0.2) I have tried changing the gateway on my server to point to pfsense (0.41), as well as trying another PC set to dhcp...neither one will reach the internet. The odd thing is...when i do an ipconfig /release/renew on a dhcp machine, it renews with the old gateway address (0.26), despite it being turned off and disconnected entirely from my network. Am i missing something?
Have you got the pfsense lan interface setup with the default ip address range ie 192.168.1.1 or have you changed the lan interface to 192.168.0.26 to be identical to your old router?