When dealing with port forwards, the destination IP is always the "internal" IP address, never a WAN address. The rule still goes on the WAN tab though. And with traffic coming from the internet, you never need to set a "source" address, that is not rewritten anywhere, and will always be the original IP.
As I mentioned in the previous message, you did not have the correct firewall rule in place to allow that traffic, which is why it was being blocked.