New PPPoE backend, some feedback

[louis2]

@RobbieTT

Be aware that I am not at all saying that a user can directly access the ISP-node, but I am sure that PPOE interface can !!

Whats ever I it helps, I am absolutely OK to activate PPOE debug logging for a short period!

Note that my actual config is like this
ISP => ISP-fiber-interface => one of my small switches => pfSense.

Internet should arrive via VLAN 6, IPTV via VLAN4 and (Old) VoIP via VLAN7.
Untagged routed to vlan1 and vlans (internet) are routed to pfSense.

I did add vlan1 to be quite sure that even untagged messages are passing to pfSense. Normally I would simply have blocked untagged. However the PPPOE is assigned to VLAN6.

[Phil2025]

@stephenw10

I've updated to the BETA 2.8.1, and the issue with the IPv6 Gateway monitoring is not fixed for me. I still need to restart the gateway service in order for monitoring to start on the IPv6 gateway.

If I can provide any more information or logs let me know.

[stephenw10]

Does the interface get an IPv6 address or is it link-local with PD only?

[Phil2025]

@stephenw10 I get a 'WAN_DHCP6' Gateway listed with a link local address (something like fe80::a96:adff:febb:f800%pppoe1), and Status is Unknown on the dashboard. I have IPv6 connectivity all okay though. Restarting the Gateway service brings the monitoring up and it goes to Online.

The DHCP6 client settings for the WAN is below. Hope that helps.

[RobbieTT]

@Phil2025
Mine, for reference:

️

[stephenw10]

Hmm, I would expect that to work. It's pretty much exactly what I run myself.

What do you see logged at boot compared with when you restart dpinger?

[azalea]

I'm seeing the IPv6 gateway monitoring issue, too. (2.8.1-RC)

But my situation is a little different. IPv6 address is set but is not reachable.

My ISP uses separate PPPoE sessions for IPv4 and IPv6.
(IPv4 username and IPv6 username are different.)

DHCP6 Client Configuration is the same as Phil2025.

Below is an IPv6-only situation. These are picked out from the perspective of the differences between if_pppoe and mpd5.

Gateways Status

[if_pppoe]
<WAN_DHCP6>
Gateway	:not displayed
Status	:Pending
<WAN_PPPOE>
Gateway	:not displayed
Status	:Pending

[mpd5]
<WAN_DHCP6(default)>
Gateway	:displayed
Status	:Online
<WAN_PPPOE>
Gateway	:not displayed
Status	:Pending

Gateways Widget

[if_pppoe]
<WAN_DHCP6>
Gateway IP Address:not displayed (tilde symbol)
Status:Unknown
<WAN_PPPOE>
Gateway IP Address:not displayed (tilde symbol)
Status:Unknown

[mpd5]
<WAN_DHCP6(Default gateway)>
Gateway IP Address:displayed
Status:Online
<WAN_PPPOE>
Gateway IP Address:not displayed (tilde symbol)
Status:Unknown

Services Status

[if_pppoe]
dpinger:Stopped (can not start)

[mpd5]
dpinger:Running

Interfaces Status

[if_pppoe]
<WAN Interface>
IPv6 Link Local	:displayed
Gateway IPv6	:not exist
<LAN Interface>
IPv6 Address	:displayed (no reachability)

[mpd5]
<WAN Interface>
IPv6 Link Local	:displayed
Gateway IPv6	:displayed
<LAN Interface>
IPv6 Address	:displayed

NDP Table
(The following is the same situation for IPv4-only.)

[if_pppoe]
WAN Interface IPv6 Link Local:not exist

[mpd5]
WAN Interface IPv6 Link Local:displayed

PPP Log

[if_pppoe]
if_pppoe: pppoe0: failed to clear IP address: 49

[mpd5]
No errors

[stephenw10]

@azalea said in New PPPoE backend, some feedback:

My ISP uses separate PPPoE sessions for IPv4 and IPv6.

Hmm, how exactly is that configured?

[azalea]

I used an IPv6-only configuration in my first report. This configuration used pppoe0 and the WAN interface for IPv6.

Below is the configuration for IPv4 and IPv6. This configuration uses pppoe0 and the WAN interface for IPv4, and pppoe1 and the OPT1 interface for IPv6.

PPP Configuration

[pppoe0]
Link Type:PPPoE
Link Interface(s):WAN port device (for example, em0)
Username:username for IPv4
Password:password for IPv4

[pppoe1]
Link Type:PPPoE
Link Interface(s):WAN port device (for example, em0)
Username:username for IPv6
Password:password for IPv6

Interface Assignments Configuration

WAN Interface:PPPOE0(em0)
LAN Interface:LAN port device (for example, em1)
OPT1 Interface:PPPOE1(em0)

WAN Interface Configuration

[General Configuration]
IPv4 Configuration Type:PPPoE
IPv6 Configuration Type:None
Others:blank

[PPPoE Configuration]
Username:username for IPv4
Password:password for IPv4
Others:blank or disabled

[Reserved Networks]
Block private networks and loopback addresses:checked
Block bogon networks:checked

LAN Interface Configuration

[General Configuration]
IPv4 Configuration Type:Static IPv4
IPv6 Configuration Type:Track Interface
Others:blank or default

[Static IPv4 Configuration]
IPv4 Address:192.168.0.254/24
IPv4 Upstream gateway:Npne

[Track IPv6 Interface]
IPv6 Interface:OPT1
IPv6 Prefix ID:0

[Reserved Networks]
Block private networks and loopback addresses:unchecked
Block bogon networks:unchecked

OPT1 Interface Configuration

[General Configuration]
IPv4 Configuration Type:PPPoE
IPv6 Configuration Type:DHCP6
Others:blank

[DHCP6 Client Configuration]
Use IPv4 connectivity as parent interface:checked
Request only an IPv6 prefix:checked
DHCPv6 Prefix Delegation size:56
Others:unchecked

[PPPoE Configuration]
Username:username for IPv6
Password:password for IPv6
Others:blank or disabled

[Reserved Networks]
Block private networks and loopback addresses:checked
Block bogon networks:checked

Gateways Configuration

[Default gateway]
Default gateway IPv4:Automatic
Default gateway IPv6:Automatic

Although it is not related to the issue, there is a mismatch in wording.
In the Gateways Status, the status of WAN_PPPOE is displayed as "Pending".
In the Gateways Widget, the status of WAN_PPPOE is displayed as "Unknown".
I think it would be better to align the expression to "Pending".

[stephenw10]

Hmm that's an interesting setup. I don't think I've ever seen that before. I assume it was working previously with mpd5/negraph?

Can you say which ISP that is?