Upload traffic not shaped

dvserg

What version are you on? ALWAYS include this information on any open source bug report.

pfSense 1.0 RC1 - this is version?

Full version on HDD (not livecd of embeded)
Platform - usual intel P2-xxx 2 interface
Configuration as filtered bridge+shaper

sullrich

update to http://www.pfsense.com/~sullrich/1.0-SNAPSHOT-09-12-06/

RC1 is OLD

dvserg

OK
May be this resolved problem :-\

sullrich

Yes.

dvserg

Not resolved :'(

Any ideas?

This msg from System log->Firewall for send my mail (SMTP=25 port)

pf: 060440 rule 286.qmailDown.2/0(match): pass in on rl0: (tos 0x0, ttl 128, id 34703, offset 0, flags [DF], proto: TCP (6), length: 48) 10.62.0.21.4881 > 213.247.196.18.25: S, cksum 0x0de1 (correct), 2977173570:2977173570(0) win 64512 <mss 1460,nop,nop,sackok="">Rule take outgouing SMTP packet But not place them to queue - work only default queue</mss>

sullrich

Post a screen shot of your traffic shapers rules section that includes the SMTP item.

Make sure you actually told it to prioritize SMTP on the others wizard screen.

dvserg

OK, but only tomorrow.
Thx

ps in firewall log present only rl0 - Lan interface messages

sullrich

It takes 1 minute total to take a screenshot.

Not sure what my schedule is tomorrow so it would be much better to post a screenshot.

Again, it only takes a mintue.

dvserg

My shape rules

shp1.jpg_thumb

sullrich

Only the default traffic shaper wizard configuration is supported right now.

Please rerun the traffic shaper wizard and test again without modifying anything.

dvserg

@sullrich:

Only the default traffic shaper wizard configuration is supported right now.

Please rerun the traffic shaper wizard and test again without modifying anything.

Nothing…

this my "worked" config - shaped only incoming
and ./tmp rulez set
file 2.exe.txt rename to 2.exe and run to unpack (rar archive)

pls look this - may be resolve problem

ps wan interface shaped only for default rule - t.e. wan interface support altq

config-router.txt

dvserg

–

2.exe.txt

sullrich

No offense but I am not running an executable from someone that I do not know.

Please post in a non virus ridden format.

dvserg

@sullrich:

No offense but I am not running an executable from someone that I do not know.

Please post in a non virus ridden format.

rules.txt
qlanacks.txt
qlandef.txt
qlanRoot.txt
qmailDown.txt
qmailUp.txt
qOthersDownH.txt
qOthersDownL.txt
qOthersUpH.txt
qOthersUpL.txt
qwanacks.txt
qwandef.txt
qwanRoot.txt
qwebDown.txt
qwebUp.txt

sullrich

Bridging interfaces + shaping does not work in 1.0.

dvserg

:-\

Ofiget.
Bridging interface can shape in theory?
Exist any other project where this worked?
I'm in bad situation :-[

sullrich

It can shape in theory but our code does not handle it. We had enough trouble getting to where we are now.

Patches accepted.

dvserg

OK

hoba

m0n0wall can shape in bridging situations. enable filtering bridge at system>advanced and set up pipes, queues and rules. m0n0's shaper is completely different though but it can shape in a bridgescenario.

Mikhail

@sullrich:

Bridging interfaces + shaping does not work in 1.0.

I have no Bridging interfaces, but outgoing traffic shaping does not work. RC3.