Miniupnpd issues with lastest snapshot

jimp

We know it's still broken, it's not supposed to be fixed yet. When a fix is checked in, we will update the ticket and this thread.

mikhe

jimp miniupnpd dated 15 Mar 19:01 from FreeBSD - same error message

Cino

??? omg

jimp thank you for all your work on this issue… Let us know when you want us to re-test. For now, my old binary that I copied over is working for me.

Topper727

I had some issue with the net dying.. DNS errors it said and got havp page. So I didn't know I repeated I thought first.. thank you for the hard work.. I will test when I see you state you resolved this issue.

geeknik

miniupnpd isn't working for me in the latest build..

2.1-BETA0 (amd64)
built on Sat Jul 21 15:31:46 EDT 2012
FreeBSD 8.3-RELEASE-p3


Jul 22 10:49:04 	miniupnpd[56051]: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device
Jul 22 10:49:04 	miniupnpd[56051]: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device
Jul 22 10:49:04 	miniupnpd[56051]: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING
Jul 22 10:49:04 	miniupnpd[56051]: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING
Jul 22 10:49:12 	miniupnpd[2786]: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device
Jul 22 10:49:12 	miniupnpd[2786]: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device
Jul 22 10:49:12 	miniupnpd[2786]: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING
Jul 22 10:49:12 	miniupnpd[2786]: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING

strumf666

Any ETA on fixing this?

LOCOLAPTOP

2.1-BETA0 (amd64)
built on Fri Jul 27 14:34:36 EDT 2012
FreeBSD 8.3-RELEASE-p3

Not working as well. :/

eri--

Please try latest snapshots it should be ok.
http://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/2527

Loke

@ermal:

Please try latest snapshots it should be ok.
http://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/2527

Latest snapshot is not working as well.

2.1-BETA0 (i386)
built on Tue Jul 31 19:07:24 EDT 2012
FreeBSD 8.3-RELEASE-p3

Aug 1 09:56:03 miniupnpd9254: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING
Aug 1 09:56:03 miniupnpd9254: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING
Aug 1 09:56:03 miniupnpd9254: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device
Aug 1 09:56:03 miniupnpd9254: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device

eri--

Can you before doing the upgrade kill miniupnd and then try the upgrade?

iFloris

My miniupnpnd is showing the same problem.
I ran killall miniupnpd and upgraded through the webinterface to no avail.

2.1-BETA0 (i386)
built on Tue Jul 31 19:07:24 EDT 2012
FreeBSD 8.3-RELEASE-p3

Aug 1 10:55:37 miniupnpd[35437]: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING
Aug 1 10:55:37 miniupnpd[35437]: Failed to init redirection engine. EXITING
Aug 1 10:55:37 miniupnpd[35437]: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device
Aug 1 10:55:37 miniupnpd[35437]: DIOCGETSTATUS: Operation not supported by device
Aug 1 10:55:37 php: /pkg_edit.php: miniupnpd: Starting service on interface: lan

jimp

Yeah that's the result of some other changes/experimenting we had been doing. It's still not 100%, next snapshot might be better, we'll have to wait and see.

tfbiii

Not working with the 8/2/2012 i386 build.

Interesting note - miniupnp does not show up on the packages screen under install OR available yet it will show up within Service Status.

Thank you for all of the work you guys do - I truly love this firewall.

-Fred

Cino

@tfbiii:

Not working with the 8/2/2012 i386 build.

Interesting note - miniupnp does not show up on the packages screen under install OR available yet it will show up within Service Status.

Thank you for all of the work you guys do - I truly love this firewall.

-Fred

its not an add-on package.. it comes pre-built with pfSense now.

strumf666

I don't see any errors in the logs, but apparently it still doesn't work:

2.1-BETA0 (amd64)
built on Fri Aug 3 00:17:11 EDT 2012

tfbiii

@Cino:

@tfbiii:

Not working with the 8/2/2012 i386 build.

Interesting note - miniupnp does not show up on the packages screen under install OR available yet it will show up within Service Status.

Thank you for all of the work you guys do - I truly love this firewall.

-Fred

its not an add-on package.. it comes pre-built with pfSense now.

Is it possible that in the move from Package to Feature there may be lingering files that should/would have been uninstalled but didn't because the package ended up getting broken somewhere along the line?

-Fred

jimp

It has not been a package since before 1.2 even. It is merely configured using the internal pkg system for its gui page. Nothing about it is a package in the binary sense, and that's what this is – an issue with the miniupnpd code/binary.

If someone in this thread has said miniupnpd "package" they meant "package" in the freebsd sense, not in pfSense.

Cybdex

I must say i kinda regret trying the 2.1 beta to see if my isp was kind enough to give me ipv6 addresses (witch they don't), and now miniupnpd not working for months..

Wish there was a easy way back to stable without having to set up everything again.

C

jimp

I'd like to see upnp work more than anyone else, but when people are real dicks about it (see https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/2527#change-9600 ), it doesn't help. It is rather discouraging.

strumf666

Well I hope you don't get discouraged about it so we'll hopefully have uPnP working soon :)