NTP Not Working [SOLVED (totally)]

[beremonavabi]

One more attempt at figuring this out.

I saw a bug report that was similar (though it involved CARP):

https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/5548

The response was:

You're breaking NTP connectivity on the backup by sending the traffic using a CARP IP. It won't, and can't, receive those replies - they go to the primary. When WAN isn't bound, it's probably hitting NAT to a CARP IP because it has a private source IP. NAT it to the WAN IP in that case.

The OP responded:

Added the following NAT rules at the top of the Outbound manual rules list:

Interfc Source Src Pt Dest Dest Pt NAT Addr NAT Pt Static Description 
WAN1 This Fw udp/* * udp/123 WAN1 addr * NO NTP to WAN1 INTFC IP 

and that fixed it.

I was wondering if my restricting all outbound traffic to go through my VPN might be causing a similar problem here. So, I added the following outbound NAT rule (even though it ought to have been covered by my existing NAT rules and I've got "redirect-gateway def1; in my VPN client Custom Options to make sure the firewall, itself, can get out the default interface) which, I think, is an equivalent:

It doesn't make any difference. NTP still won't start without the WAN being selected. Can anyone confirm that these situations might be equivalent and that the NAT rule I added makes some kind of sense?

[stephenw10]

Can we see your full outbound NAT page?

Steve

[beremonavabi]

@stephenw10

[stephenw10]

Hmm, looks OK. And you're using manual mode there or hybrid?

The the WAN the default gateway on your system?

Is default gateway switching enabled?

I could imagine NTP trying to use the VPN gateway and sourcing from something not NAT'd there. It should always use the default gateway though.

Steve

[beremonavabi]

@stephenw10 said in NTP Not Working [SOLVED (mostly)]:

Hmm, looks OK. And you're using manual mode there or hybrid?

The the WAN the default gateway on your system?

Is default gateway switching enabled?

I could imagine NTP trying to use the VPN gateway and sourcing from something not NAT'd there. It should always use the default gateway though.

Steve

Manual mode and, yes, the WAN is the default gateway. Default gateway switching is OFF under System > Advanced > Miscellaneous.

In normal operation, everything is on the VPN_LAN interface (192.168.20.0/24). My firewall rules for that are:

The first two rules are special cases that are hardly ever used. The third rule sends local device traffic to other local devices out the default. And the last rule sends traffic to the outside world out via the VPN's Gateway Group. So, in general, everything to the outside world goes out over the VPN via that Gateway Group. But, I've got "redirect-gateway def1;" in my VPN client Custom Options to make sure the firewall, itself, can still get out the default gateway. I assume NTP falls under that and should get out via the WAN.

That special Outbound NAT rule with "This Firewall", above, was just a desperate stab at trying to make sure that NTP traffic could get out the WAN and not get stuck by the VPN. But, it didn't work. Assuming I wrote that rule correctly, it doesn't look like that's the issue.

I wonder if it could be a DNS issue (not being able to resolve the NTP pool names to addresses -- though why adding the WAN to the NTP listening interfaces would "fix" that, I don't know). I'm using DNS Resolver in NON-Forwarding mode. It's active for all my local LAN-type interfaces (not WAN) and sends everything out via the VPNx_WAN interfaces (again, not WAN). I wonder if I should add the WAN to the Outgoing Network Interfaces:

[beremonavabi]

@beremonavabi
It doesn't look like it's a DNS issue, either. I stuck the actual IP address for a public DNS server

http://support.ntp.org/bin/view/Servers/PublicTimeServer000011

in and removed the WAN interface. Same problem: NTP doesn't start. Put the WAN back in the list and all was well.

[beremonavabi]

Still not working without WAN selected in Settings > NTP. For posterity, here's some information on my gateways:

RW_VPN is my VPN server, VPNx_WAN are my two VPN clients, IPv6 is off so all the IPV6 gateways are disabled, and I've scribbled over my WAN_DHCP addresses for privacy purposes.

I've also got a Gateway Group:

[johnpoz]

See that other thread on how dicked up the other guys setup was to why it wasn't working.. A clue to why yours isn't working is prob in there as well.

[johnpoz]

@beremonavabi said in NTP Not Working [SOLVED (mostly)]:

RW_VPN is my VPN server

Huh? Why would you vpn server your running on pfsense be setup as a gateway?

Looks like he is shooting himself in the foot same way other guy was... Manual mode outbound nat and not natting what the ntp is trying to use as the source IP, etc.

And for what reason are you using manual for your outbound nat?

[Gertjan]

Just thinking and typing out loud :

Is this not just another case of trying to pass everything through the VPN tunnel ?

Knowing that the ntp deamon probably starts before the VPN server, it will work for a while : the WAN connections works, (NAT) rules are fine.
Then the VPN server starts, the gateways are shot in the back and reconstructed, so that all traffic goes out of the VPN, the new "WAN".
Our ntp isn't informed, and is locked out.

Something like that ?

[jimp]

Firewall > NAT, Outbound tab. Add rule to top.

• Disabled: Unchecked
• Do not NAT: Unchecked
• Interface: WAN (make one of these rules for each WAN)
• Protocol: any
• Source: This Firewall (self)
• Destination: any
• Not: Unchecked
• Translation Address: Interface Address
• Port or Range: Blank
• Description: NAT anything out from the firewall itself

[beremonavabi]

@jimp said in NTP Not Working [SOLVED (mostly)]:

Firewall > NAT, Outbound tab. Add rule to top.

Disabled: Unchecked
Do not NAT: Unchecked
Interface: WAN (make one of these rules for each WAN)
Protocol: any
Source: This Firewall (self)
Destination: any
Not: Unchecked
Translation Address: Interface Address
Port or Range: Blank
Description: NAT anything out from the firewall itself

Yay! Thanks, jimp. That got it. I had to reboot the pfSense box before it would work, though. I'd tried something similar a couple of weeks ago, but it was limited to UDP on port 123, was at the end of my list of outbound NAT rules, and, probably most importantly, I didn't reboot the box.

[jimp]

You probably didn't need to reboot, just clear the states table (Diagnostics > States, Reset States tab)

[PTZ-M]

@jimp This rule does not work for me. Rather, it works, but before the first reboot of PfSense.

[jimp]

Then you have a different issue than the OP of this thread. Start a new thread with details about your own setup.