Not getting properthroughput on gigabit devices. 200mbps when it should be at least 600mbps

Derelict · Aug 31, 2020, 8:34 PM

Get something with two intel PCIe NICs, idk, a lower-power Core i3 maybe. Might as well get something that has AES-NI going. An Atom C2000 maybe. You'll get 600 down or it's not the firewall.

Derelict · Aug 31, 2020, 8:35 PM

@Berzerk said in Not getting properthroughput on gigabit devices. 200mbps when it should be at least 600mbps:

You have no idea just how cheap I am.

Good, Cheap, Fast. Pick two.

Berzerk · Aug 31, 2020, 8:38 PM

I choose cheap and fast? :)

Derelict · Aug 31, 2020, 8:43 PM

It won't be good.

stephenw10 · Aug 31, 2020, 8:47 PM

You can try the alternate Realtek driver, nothing much to lose by doing so.

Yeah some of it is clearly in the FreeBSD default driver. There were also a lot of different models supported by that driver with different levels of crappyness!
Disable all the hardware off-loading, often broken for Realtek.

A device needs to have Gigabit NICs if it needs to pass more then 100Mbps. That doesn't mean it can pass 1Gbps. The same is true for 10GbE ports currently.

I would think you could well be hitting some limitation in the PCMCIA there if it's actually that and not cardbus or whatever was after that.

Actually passing 600Mbps of just firewall & NAT doesn't require much CPU power. As I said I could do it with a C2D E4500 quite easily. An old school Atom D525 will pass ~500Mbps.

Steve

johnpoz · Aug 31, 2020, 8:53 PM

@stephenw10 said in Not getting properthroughput on gigabit devices. 200mbps when it should be at least 600mbps:

some limitation in the PCMCIA

I haven't even seen a laptop with pcmcia in over 10 years for sure.. Use to be for like a modem, or a 10/100 ethernet.. Use to have some G wifi cards, etc.. I find it highly highly unlikely that anything pcmcia could push anything close to gig.. That your seeing even 200 surprises me.

Derelict · Aug 31, 2020, 8:58 PM

I threw away a PCMCIA bluetooth adapter yesterday.

Berzerk · Aug 31, 2020, 8:58 PM

@Derelict I've got a core 2 quad with an onboard intel, and I'm ordering an intel pcie now. 6gb ram as well. Should work.

JKnott · Aug 31, 2020, 9:00 PM

@stephenw10

All this talk about interfaces and brands has me wondering about my system.

Here's what I have
LAN bge0 (Broadcom?)
WAN re0 (Realtek?)
Test em0 (Intel?)

Perhaps I should swap WAN and Test. LAN is the mom board interface, which I'd rather have connected to the LAN.

johnpoz · Aug 31, 2020, 9:01 PM

@Derelict said in Not getting properthroughput on gigabit devices. 200mbps when it should be at least 600mbps:

I threw away a PCMCIA bluetooth adapter yesterday.

Look what I just found on one of my shelves - yeah this is going in the trash ;)

login-to-view

Berzerk · Aug 31, 2020, 9:03 PM

@johnpoz
You guys would have a meltdown if you saw the Hardware I had lying around.

I had a 1/2speed cdrom that you loaded with a caddy for the longest time.

There was a 10MB 50lb MFM HD around here somewhere . . . I could open a museum.

Be thankful I set core 2 duos as the oldest I would let on the network.

johnpoz · Aug 31, 2020, 9:03 PM

@Derelict So you drove/shipped that all the way to TN, just to throw it away - hehehhe

stephenw10 · Aug 31, 2020, 9:04 PM

@JKnott said in Not getting properthroughput on gigabit devices. 200mbps when it should be at least 600mbps:

Perhaps I should swap WAN and Test.

Yup, I would.

JKnott · Aug 31, 2020, 9:04 PM

@johnpoz said in Not getting properthroughput on gigabit devices. 200mbps when it should be at least 600mbps:

Look what I just found on one of my shelves - yeah this is going in the trash ;)

I could have used that years ago, with my first ThinkPad. It came with 802.11b only WiFi, which I replaced with one capable of g. However, in the swap, I lost my dial up modem.

My current ThinkPad has n on 2.4 GHz only, though it's apparently possible to replace that with a dual band card.

I also have a 10 Mb hub here.

johnpoz · Aug 31, 2020, 9:07 PM

Why do you I still have these??

login-to-view

Best part of this thread is cleaned up some junk ;)

stephenw10 · Aug 31, 2020, 9:08 PM

Haha.

That's not even Cardbus... like 16bit? Rapido!

akuma1x · Aug 31, 2020, 9:08 PM

@Berzerk said in Not getting properthroughput on gigabit devices. 200mbps when it should be at least 600mbps:

@johnpoz
You guys would have a meltdown if you saw the Hardware I had lying around.

Dude, time to throw stuff away! It's nostalgic and all, but old tech is rarely useful.

Jeff

Berzerk · Aug 31, 2020, 9:13 PM

@johnpoz
This is one of the cards I'm using.
login-to-view

johnpoz · Aug 31, 2020, 9:15 PM

Early part of the pandemic - looking for shit to do I cleaned out my shelves and threw away a bunch of junk... Got some frustration out breaking up some old hard drives.. The really not that old 2.5 disks are nice but too small in size to do anything with - you hit them with a hammer and platters just shatter like glass and its like they are full of pebbles or sand when you shake them.. That was fun! ;)

Threw out some old floppy drives.. Just taking up space, etc..

But these old pcmcia cards were on the top of my desk - and got missed.. They are in the trash now... heheheh.. Even the oldest laptop I have, which should prob throw out doesn't even have a slot for them.

edit: Wow.. But just because it says gig on it, doesn't mean it can actually do anything close to it ;)

Berzerk · Aug 31, 2020, 9:16 PM

@akuma1x

I've actually found old tech to be quite useful, in many circumstances.