@Gblenn said in Unable to do Open NAT in pfSense 2.7.2-RELEASE:

When testing some of these things, it's always a good idea to do ipconfig /release and ipconfig /renew on the gaming PC after making changes. Also to reset UPnP so that any reserved ports are released and can be requested again.

Yeah, I keep spamming those commands in the terminal window and also I restart upnp or remove the states from the states table that belong to my IP address.

Here are the latest entries from Status > System Logs > System > Routing.

07ed1476-7ab1-457f-8641-ab1245d40610-image.png

01:25 was the time I restarted upnp. I am a bit concerned about those "Invalid argument" messages.
08:57 - that IP belongs to my brother's phone, I don't know what he did at that time, should I ask?
He did a test though using that test site, but earlier, around 08:44. He used his phone, which is not configured. I told him to test on his PC, which is. But none of those attempts show up here.
10:04 is when I turned on my PC. I am concerned about those time outs, and then there is an error.

How can I resolve that invalid argument and time out issues?

@stephenw10 Managed to solve it myself. I don't know how I missed this before when I created the VLAN's I created them on igb2 rather than igb1 which is where my LAN network resides. I changed that and now everything is working fine as it was before I started a fresh configuration. Thank you for the suggestions anyway!

@Chris78 Sorry to sort of resurrect this.. I went through all of the instructions , my intent was to have all traffic go through the VPN yet no luck :(
Could pfBlockerNG be the cause?
I'll admit this is a LOT of steps to go through and so much could go wrong

Thank you