@bbcan177 Thank you, thank you, thank you!!! The "Suppression" option was disabled and enabling fixed the problem. The 192.168.1.1 IP is now begin removed from the URLhaus blacklist.
I think I also now understand the ALIAS solution. I would need to convert ALL pfB lists to aliases and completely forgo the auto rules. This seems to be good practice in general and I may consider this.
Finally, I do plan on updating to the devel version eventually, probably when I update to pfSense 2.5.0 in the future. This will take some time and I need to make sure I carve the time out from my schedule to address the issue. Right now, I am too busy at work and need the internet to just work for my video conferences.