Pfsense won't recognize network card

[firefox]

It's already enabled

[kpa]

My guess is that the BIOS is set to automatically disable the built-in NIC in case there's an add-on card installed, that makes sort of sense in a desktop system but is nonsense on a server type system.

I'd also guess that the developers of the Linux driver have found a way to enable the integrated Broadcom NIC regardless but the FreeBSD driver doesn't have the same workaround.

[stephenw10]

pfSense is able to attach to the Broadcom card and it can be assigned when the Realtek card is not in the box?

If that's the case then I'd throw the Realtek card away an look for something else. The rtl8139 is a truly terrible NIC.

https://github.com/pfsense/FreeBSD-src/blob/db53f09b3a68bfa850844e88c97535f277db4d71/sys/dev/rl/if_rl.c#L48

Steve

[Guest]

"snip"```
WARNING: you should run this program as super-user.
ubuntu                   
    description: Computer
    width: 32 bits

This is under Linux (Ubuntu) and pfSense is based on FreeBSD and also could it be that this PC
or pfSense box is a 32Bit version and you try out to install pfSensen version 2.4.0 that is coming
only as a 64Bit version!!!

Often, but not even, in the BIOS could be also set another Interrupt to many onboards NICs because
tey are shared together with some PCIe slots, perhaps this might be then also the case here? Please
have a look on this too.

[firefox]

@kpa:

My guess is that the BIOS is set to automatically disable the built-in NIC in case there's an add-on card installed, that makes sort of sense in a desktop system but is nonsense on a server type system.

I'd also guess that the developers of the Linux driver have found a way to enable the integrated Broadcom NIC regardless but the FreeBSD driver doesn't have the same workaround.

The BIOS option associated with a network card is only
Whether to enabled the card or not to enabled

There is another option related to pxe boot (I added a screenshot)
I tried to run the system when the options are enabled. The same result

@stephenw10:

pfSense is able to attach to the Broadcom card and it can be assigned when the Realtek card is not in the box?

If that's the case then I'd throw the Realtek card away an look for something else. The rtl8139 is a truly terrible NIC.

https://github.com/pfsense/FreeBSD-src/blob/db53f09b3a68bfa850844e88c97535f277db4d71/sys/dev/rl/if_rl.c#L48

Steve

yes as i said
When I remove the external network card from the computer
And runs the system without the external card then pfsense recognizes the internal network card properly

I'll try another card

@BlueKobold:

"snip"```
WARNING: you should run this program as super-user.
ubuntu                   
    description: Computer
    width: 32 bits

This is under Linux (Ubuntu) and pfSense is based on FreeBSD and also could it be that this PC
or pfSense box is a 32Bit version and you try out to install pfSensen version 2.4.0 that is coming
only as a 64Bit version!!!

Often, but not even, in the BIOS could be also set another Interrupt to many onboards NICs because
tey are shared together with some PCIe slots, perhaps this might be then also the case here? Please
have a look on this too.

I checked to see if it was suitable for 64 bit
i use this program https://www.grc.com/securable.htm
it give me The processor is 64 bit compatible


[firefox]

Update
I brought four more network cards
That means there are currently 5 network cards
4 with pci connection
1 with pci-e-x1 connection

I tried to change
And those are the results

Three of the cards with a pci connection
Once I connect the network card to the computer
I get the same result as the first network card
The system identifies only the external card but not the internal one

On one card with a pci-e-x1 connection
When I connect it to a computer
The system identifies the internal card and not the external one

And the last card with a pci connection
Same
The system identifies the internal card and not the external one

All cards are valid and working on windows xp / windows 7 / linux

[stephenw10]

@firefox:

All cards are valid and working on windows xp / windows 7 / linux

On the same motherboard?

It does look like that card is being disabled by attaching a different card. Can you not just use two additional NICs?

Steve

[firefox]

@stephenw10:

@firefox:

All cards are valid and working on windows xp / windows 7 / linux

On the same motherboard?

It does look like that card is being disabled by attaching a different card. Can you not just use two additional NICs?

Steve

yes on the same motherboard

i can use two additional cards

but the one i want to use is 10/100/1000
and all the other 4 is 10/100
the one on the boars is 10/100/1000

I'll give it another try
I will try to get network cards that they are 10/100/1000

The reason for all this is
That my current system is 32 bit
With 1.5 GHz memory and 10/100 network cards
And there is no upgrade to 32 bit

This computer I'm trying to install on is
With 4GB memory
And a 10/100/1000 network card

[stephenw10]

Do you need more that 100Mbps? Having just one Gigabit NIC isn't going to help much, except maybe if you're using VLANs.

There appears to be some basic low level incompatibility with that on-board NIC and I don't think we are going to be able to help you with it.

pfSense 2.3.X will be supported for ~1 year so there's no rush to upgrade.

Steve

[kejianshi]

If after much trying you just can't get things to work, I suggest adding a cheap intel nic you buy off ebay for $10.

Get two and replace your current add-on card…  It will save you trouble down the road.  Make sure whatever you buy has native support for netmap.

Suricata needs it to work in inline mode.  It might save you trouble later.

[firefox]

Do you need more that 100Mbps?

we have connections up to 500 MB

If after much trying you just can't get things to work, I suggest adding a cheap intel nic you buy off ebay for $10.

As I wrote I will try to retrieve other network cards
And if it does not work
Then another computer

In any case, thanks to everyone who tried to help

[kejianshi]

Network cards are usually cheaper than computers.

[firefox]

updating
I brought four new Intel network cards
With pci connection
And another Intel card with a pci-x connection
pfsense does not recognize any of them
I tried to connect two together or separately
The same result

If Windows 2000 recognizes the network cards
(I connected two cards and the computer recognized the other two cards and the card on the board)
So pfsense should also identify them without problems

Another question that may be related

When I installed the pfsense 2.4.0
The installation process was different from what I know
Perhaps I needed to do something different for pfsense to recognize the network cards ?

[Guest]

You need to assign them to interfaces.

[firefox]

I know that
The problem is that pfsense not even recognize the cards as if there is nothing there

[Guest]

what does pciconf show

[firefox]

That's what happens after I put the two Intel network cards
It does not even reach the stage where i need to assign them to interfaces

(Attached image)

[stephenw10]

There's a bug in the ACPI code showing there. Are you on the latest BIOS version for that board?

Steve

[firefox]

yes I updated it before installing the pfsense
I have also tried to install with one bios before and one before that
It gave the same result

So the problem here is the bios (or the bios code)?
If there is no new bios (and there is no)
So there is nothing to do ?

[stephenw10]

Yeah, that is possible. Though it's non-trivial.

You might try booting a live Linux CD to see if it also hits that issue. A lot of times the ACPI will have sections written specifically for Windows and everything else just has to fall back to the defaults or have nothing at all. Board manufacturers usually only claim to support Windows so other OSes are SoL!

https://docs.freebsd.org/doc/10.0-RELEASE/usr/local/share/doc/freebsd/handbook/ACPI-debug.html

Steve