@colonnesel said in Need to allow access to specific corporate network IP from guest network:
Rookie mistake
Not sure I would say that - it does come up quite a bit around here to be honest.. Quite often users policy routing and wondering why they can not get to some other vlan, etc.
I honestly have no idea why I would've thought that to be honest because it makes no sense.
Huh - if you understand how the rules are evaluated, and how policy routing works then its quite clear that if you forced traffic out a gateway that can not get to where you want to go.. you wouldn't be able to get there..
To be honest I would be disappointed if I had a rule that said use this gateway, and this was first in my rules, and it didn't send traffic down that gateway even if there was another route.. If that is how it "should" work per what @stephenw10 has mentioned. That really should be CLEARLY stated that it will work that way.. Which in 10 some years using pfsense, do not recall it ever doing that with any sort of negate rules, etc.
That is what can happen if the gateway your forcing traffic out is DOWN, and you have setting to not use that rule if gateway goes down, etc. But if the gateway is UP, and rule is before another rule - then it should force the traffic out the gateway.
[image: 1637352599404-skiprules.jpg]