@koby-peleg-hen well you do you - but I never got why anyone would ever do this.. Did you get it free - if so I could attempt to use one of their certs. Looks like not single domain 78$ for six years.
For starters I don't ever see using an actual public domain on my pfsense gui? I own multiple domains, don't use any of them internally.. Pointless to do so.. I use local.lan - but at some point will switch over to home.arpa for local domain.
But if did want to use public - why not just use free ACME cert?
So did you create the CSR and have them sign it? How exactly did you go about getting the cert and key..
Without some actual details, going to be impossible to help figure out what is wrong. What does the log say? You can setup pfsense to allow both http and https access - so even if the gui doesn't like the cert for some reason, the gui should be available just over http so you can see the log, etc.