@BBcan177: BTW… I'm the dev of the package and the last time I looked... I do this all for FREE and on my own time... What have you done... And from those of us who do listen… whom you have helped...  Thank you SO MUCH! I won't say its perfect (and I don't think you would either), but with a little tweaking here and there, random updates to block or allow lists, it works damn well.  I'm amazed at the numbers that build in the dash widget. Similar thanks go out to Bill for Snort too! Rick

@BBcan177: Before you run "Force Update", delete the two files: /var/db/pfblockerng/permit/pfB_google_ipv4    (Change permit and filename as required) /var/db/pfblockerng/permit/pfB_google_ipv6 The error persisted. But I found where the bug is. My list Header/Label was "Google IPv4" (with space). When I force update, it generates the "/var/db/pfblockerng/permit/Google IPv4.txt" file and I get the message: ... ===[  IPv4 Process  ]================================================= [ Google IPv4 ] Downloading update  .. completed ..   Empty file, Adding '1.1.1.1' to avoid download failure. ... I changed the Header/Label to "Google_IPv4" (space -> underscore) and now it is working as expected.

Can you PM me the contents of those two files (If there still is an error)… I can't do much without seeing the file contents when there is an error message...

In this case I wasn't concerned about the sigma list because I thought you meant by being unreliable it generated false positives, not corruption. We proved it wasn't the IPs in the list that were the problem, so I dismissed sigmalist as the problem. I didn't expect corruption to join the party. I guess it's good you discovered it because this could potentially happen with any other list, not just sigma. That was very good sleuthing! When I extracted the file on windows the smallest network in the list was a /10. Can I add a bug/feature report somewhere to add corruption checking on compressed lists? The country file is in the alias native so I can customize the order. see image i sent you. I''m assuming this is okay. EDIT: What about the sigma block showing up as a goodCountries alias in the log? Is this resolved because of the corruption or is this caused because of the way I'm using aliases? (or is there a 3rd option?) EDIT2: I couldn't stand that /3 got by me so I re-added them to pfSense and you're right. (should I be surprised I got a different result on windows?) . Wish I sorted by network size to begin with! EDIT3: Dug in some more to see whats up with the Alerts tab. I'm not sure how this works but based on how slow the page loads, I'm guessing that the block list information isn't stored in a logfile but instead the blocked IP is matched to a list dynamically so depending on how that works, I'm guessing a corrupt list could cause the log to malfunction. It seems to be working fine as of now. I looked through a few pages and looks like I would expect. https://s3.amazonaws.com/uploads.hipchat.com/9809/24877/2tOJuorc3rqUbcv/upload.png

I'm sorry to make you not happy. I'm here just want a fix, not a workaround: Is 192.168.1.100 a part of LAN net?  YES Is my firewall rule defined wrong:  Allowing OPT access all interfaces except LAN?  NO Should 192.168.1.100 be blocked by the rule:  YES, BUT its not blocking anymore. Again, I'm sorry made you feel so angry.  but thats the issue I'm having.  The rule was working perfectly until I installed your package, so of course, I need to ask you about this first,  if you think its not your package issue, then I will ask pfSense teams.

Nothing strange there. Would you mind posting a screenshot of the pfBlockerNG dashboard widget. Edit: I forgot that you posted the widget before. I don't see any issues with what your posting. Have you tried a reboot or a filter reload?  You are also on pfSense  v2.04, maybe update to 2.2.6?

Go to pfBlockerNG \ DNSBL then scroll down to the very bottom and add www.googleadservices.com then save, switch to the Update tab and force a reload.

When you install the package, it downloads the latest MaxMind GeoIP files. Those are updated the first Tuesday of each month. You will need to download those files as required. In the General tab, click the checkbox to disable the cron download of the MaxMind files. MaxMind files are saved in:  /usr/pbi/pfblockerng-amd64/share/GeoIP    (amd64 or i386) (You will need to extract these files into that folder) http://geolite.maxmind.com/download/geoip/database/GeoLiteCountry/GeoIP.dat.gz http://geolite.maxmind.com/download/geoip/database/GeoIPv6.dat.gz http://geolite.maxmind.com/download/geoip/database/GeoIPv6.csv.gz http://geolite.maxmind.com/download/geoip/database/GeoIPCountryCSV.zip Followed by executing these two commands to convert the MaxMind files for pfBNG: php /usr/local/www/pfblockerng/pfblockerng.php gc php /usr/local/www/pfblockerng/pfblockerng.php uc In the IPv4/v6/DNSBL Feeds tabs, you can enter a local address in the "Source Fields". Hope that gets you started!

Hi pf3000, Thanks for the reply. So this is what i tried nothing makes sense anymore  :-\ Tried OpenDNS and it was working blocking the typical facebook then i went to navigate whatsapp.com also gets blocked but I connect my iphone immediately it connects to whatsapp. So failed miserably Then tried DNSBL when I did the Enable Domain/AS check it and added the list from the site you sent me and nothing :( but whats odd it shows that it gets blocked on the logs of the firewall I have no clue what is whatsapp servers doing. EDIT: BAM just blocked it it was using some IPs from amazon finally…. the whatsapp.txt has been updated I will keep it updated. I wonder how long until they update it :( http://www.mediafire.com/view/xnnzh0d00kbffpu/whatsapp.txt

ok. thanks for the confirmation, although I think that default behaviour (e.g. auto-creating of "wide-open"-NAT-roules) should be changed.

@repa: I think, we can't get this working with pfBlockerNG, right ? Yes

What browser are you using? Are you on a multi-subnet network? Ensure that you can ping and browse to the DNSBL VIP address.

pfBNG 2.0.4 on 2.2.6. See extra.log Hmmm, when on .ro. (read-only) access to the filesystem seems a failure and when on .rw. it looks OK, but then dnsbl.log is reporting writing problems ? Besides in both cases I see double entries about download reports. So what is in general the supposed state (ro or rw) for using pfBNG ? extras.txt

Including some pfBlockerNG config screenshots              

Yes, you can ignore those warning during a re-installation. During a re-install, all of the pfBlockerNG Aliases are removed and re-added at the end of the pkg installation. Since you manually added pfBlockerNG (alias) Firewall rules, there is a small window of time, where the pfBlockerNG alias does not exist, and you will get those warnings.  I don't have a workaround for that unfortunately.

I was using premium for some time and in my experience it does not worth because free list from same provider blocks more than enough. Premium lists had maybe 4% blocked packages compering free ones. If you thing 4% is worth, well :) Cheers.

Those are other issues are not related to your issue… How large is your pfSense Firewall log? Looks like that entry value is too large? Status: System Logs: Settings: GUI Log Entries to Display?

@doktornotor: There's a setting to limit the number of lines in the log file on the General tab… Ah thanks, I overlooked the variable. That 20000 will be about 5MB and 10% /var increase and then no problem for me. I'll check if/how it pans out.

lol Confirmed, and thanks for the Heads up on the path change :)