I did some troubleshooting and I honestly don't know exactly what the issue was but here is a list of steps I took to get it working again:
General Setup Set loopback address on top followed by DNS IP(s) or leave everything blank if only using Unbound DNS Server Override unchecked Disable DNS Forwarder unchecked DNS Resolver Network Interfaces > only select local ints including LAN. DNS Query Forwarding unchecked DHCP Registration checked Static DHCP checked DHCP Server set your DNS Server to the LAN's IP int On each of your DHCP Clients Renew lease or perform a network reset On each of your Static Clients Use the IP int as DNS address