Matching traffic is primarily a firewall rule issue not a queues issue.
If floating rules did not work, there would be many people reporting problems, but they aren't…
When did I say queues match traffic?
I never said either that it doesnt work full stop, I said 2 things.
1 - The FreeBSD documention does not state to use match rules for traffic classification for shaping purposes. So basically my results match what the developers of PF have documented. But they do not match what the pfSense developers have documented.
2 - It isnt working in my case with my configuration.
It is a strange way to decide if something is a bug just based on that it works for many people. It may make it less likely to be a bug if it affects less people but it doesnt make it impossible.
As I said before to you KOM, you have not requested any details of me. I have already provided lots of information.
I provided the following.
step by step process to get to where I am
information on my network setup
information on my wan setup
what options I chose in the wizard
the hardware I am using
I even now have posted screenshots of my floating rules, which would only be requested when someone doubts what I am saying.
Also this thread is different to the other thread and we should avoid mixing the 2 up.
This thread was a simply question on the correct syntax to give to PF on how to match ack packets.
I of course asked it as I mistakenly thought they were not been matched due to incorrect flags in the rules before I discovered it was the 'match' issue.