@ldl said in Newbie questions:
@Gblenn Replacing my asus router with something newer, as the Asus one is outdated (the main reason), sure still works but yeah.
Another reason as to why I want to replace it, is that if I'm going to use my own router, then other people in my house will obviously be on the same line, so I want to accommodate them as well, because currently, they're not on my router as that's in another room, they're on the ISP router,
I get that the it's outdated, and of course you should try to do 2.5G on the WAN. That all makes sense, but you should only have one router in use.
And it seems to me like you are using your routers as a way to connect peoples devices so they can get out on the internet. But that's what switches are for, and they are way cheaper per port.
I will be considering upgrading the NICs and switches in the future however if I feel the need for more than 1Gb
What's the cost of these routers you are looking at?
I'm guessing you could get a 2.5Gbit dual NIC card (to upgrade pfsense with) plus one or two managed Netgear or TPLink switches for the same price.
And if you want to segment your network to separate users from each other, use VLANs. You have your Cisco switch, and if you add more VLAN capable switches you have full control. And your dumb Netgear can still be used for extra ports towards users or devices that all belong to the same VLAN.
But you do all of this having pfsense as your one and only router, connected to the ISP ONT. And you can still use the Asus and even the old ISP router as wifi AP's. But then they are no longer routers they are just semi smart switches with wifi.