@pi said in Can a modem/router combo & Netgate SG-1100:
@Raffi_ said in Can a modem/router combo & Netgate SG-1100:
@stephenw10 said in Can a modem/router combo & Netgate SG-1100:
I'm not sure how you could use the wifi parts of a modem/router when it's in bridge mode since it will not have a public IP itself.
I guess I could imagine using it to access the modem for admin purposes.
Even if it were possible in some roundabout way with VLANs it's impossible to recommend a setup like that unless you really had no other choice.
If you want to filter all your traffic through the SG-1100 put the modem in bridge mode and forget about using the wifi on it.
Steve
I second this. I think you have to choose if you want it to be a modem or wifi access point. If your ISP is charging a modem rental fee, then replacing it makes sense. Put it in bridge mode, you'll most likely sacrifice the wifi capability, but you'll be avoiding that fee. If the ISP is giving you the modem for free, then use the Motorola as a wifi access point. Disable, all services like DHCP and only use the LAN ports on the Motorola. The LAN from the Motorola can go to Opt 1.
This sounds like a good idea. I’ll try that out
Make sure to check with the ISP on the modem fee though. Because even ISP's that state the modem is "free", it never really is, they just include it in the cost. What I mean by that is unless you explicitly ask if there is a discount on your bill for BYOD, they will get away with billing you for that "free" modem. In other words, they should give you credit for your own device even if they're not billing you for their modem. If they don't offer credit, or they really aren't billing you for it, then wifi it up.