@bwanajag said in Problems pinging between IPs on a VLAN subnet:
I understand clients on the same subnet do not need to route, but I don't understand why that means devices on a given subnet won't respond to pings from another device on the same subnet.
pfSense is issuing IP addresses to devices connected to the VLAN (DHCP is working), but I cannot ping those devices from the ping tool within pfSense. Is this normal?
One all devices have received their DHCP addresses, you could disconnect pfSense from the network entirely and it should not make a bit of difference between devices on the same subnet. Your problem is with those devices, not pfSense.