Trying to find a solution to this as well. It doesn't seem OpenVPN has an option to forward headers which basically makes it impossible to use openvpn as the primary on port 443 if you need to see client IP addresses on haproxy..
As an alternative, I wondered if it might make sense to set haproxy listening on 443 and OpenVPN as a backend on a different port. Has anyone tried this yet? Does this cause double encryption (slow down the connection too much)? Here is an example of one guy who claims to have got it working:
https://discourse.haproxy.org/t/haproxy-with-openvpn-over-tcp-443-on-pfsense/4731/2
EDIT
It looks like he create a TCP frontend on 443 with a default backend going to OpenVPN:TCP:1194 and an acl that checks for SSL and sends SSL traffic to an HTTPS Backend set to localhost:9443. Then he configured localhost:9443 as a Frontend that handles the forwarded Web Traffic.
That looks like it should work, but It's a bit too complicated for me to test on my live server right now and I don't have a lab setup. Happy to help anyone else who might have a lab environment setup for testing.