This seems connected to this issue https://forum.netgate.com/topic/114786/pppoe-disconnects-requiring-reboot/2

Got it all up and running thanks! Eddie

@juelmk said in No inbound traffic coming into my WAN: When I set my WAN interface to get dhcp address from the modem it get 0.0.0.0 Well then how would it work? You sure your own the pfsense wan interface plugged into your router? You sure the cable is good? When pfsense does get an IP you need to make sure that your wan and lan of pfsense do not overlap - ie they can not be the same network 192.168.0/24 for example

Nat reflection is ALWAYS the worse option to choose.. I don't understand why anyone would ever want to nat reflect.. if host.domain.tld is on the same network next to you - then why would you not just resolve host.domain.tld to that IP.. Why would you ever want to go to the public IP to be reflected back in?? As to forwarding port X to port Y.. That is always a work around in itself to all to go to the same service with the limitation of napt and only 1 public IP, etc. If you want to go to host.domain.tld:port then go there where host.domain.tld resolves to the local IP and not the public ip..